基于ProdSI-FANP的可持续制造调度指标体系及评价决策

doi:10.3901/JME.260589

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 针对当前生产调度领域缺乏全面可持续性评价的问题，着重研究具有通用性的可持续调度指标体系以及生产调度多维度可持续性评价决策方法。首先，在指标提取和筛选的基础上，提出统一符号范式下的定量化分析方法；其次，从三基线原则(Triple bottom line,TBL)出发，基于产品可持续指数(Product sustainability index,ProdSI)构建五层结构的生产调度三维指标体系；再次，设计基于模糊理论的改进网络分析法(Fuzzy analytic network process,FANP)更好地反映专家在复杂体系赋权评分中的主观偏向，并提出ProdSI-FANP算法架构实现调度方案的综合可持续性评价。最后，面向典型柔性作业车间生产场景对评价效果进行分析，结果表明，所提体系与评价方法可从多角度为制造企业生产调度的评价决策和可持续转型提供理论支撑和方案参考。

关键词: 可持续, 生产调度, 指标体系, 网络分析法, 模糊理论

Abstract: Aiming at the lack of comprehensive sustainability evaluation in the current production scheduling field, the research focuses on the universal sustainable scheduling index system and the multi-dimensional sustainability evaluation decision-making method of production scheduling. First, on the basis of index extraction and screening, the quantitative description analysis method with unified symbolic paradigm is proposed. Secondly, starting from the triple bottom line (TBL) principles, based on the product sustainability index (ProdSI), a five-tiered production scheduling three-dimensional indicator system is constructed. Thirdly, an improved network analysis method based on fuzzy theory (FANP) is designed to better reflect the subjective bias of experts in the weighting and scoring of complex systems, and the ProdSI-FANP algorithm architecture is proposed to realize the comprehensive sustainability evaluation of dispatching schemes. Finally, the evaluation effect is analyzed for typical flexible job shop production scenarios. The results show that the proposed system and evaluation method can provide theoretical support and program reference from multiple perspective for the evaluation decision and sustainable transformation of production scheduling in manufacturing enterprises.

Key words: sustainability, production scheduling, indicator system, network analysis method, fuzzy theory

中图分类号:

TH165
TP18

王俊凯, 闫桂晨, 尤仕琦, 王海璇, 张鹏, 乔非, 王力翚. 基于ProdSI-FANP的可持续制造调度指标体系及评价决策[J]. 机械工程学报, 2026, 62(11): 61-75.

WANG Junkai, YAN Guichen, YOU Shiqi, WANG Haixuan, ZHANG Peng, QIAO Fei, WANG Lihui. Indicator System and Evaluation Decision-making for Sustainable Manufacturing Scheduling Based on ProdSI-FANP[J]. Journal of Mechanical Engineering, 2026, 62(11): 61-75.

导出引用管理器 EndNote|Reference Manager|ProCite|BibTeX|RefWorks

链接本文: http://www.cjmenet.com.cn/CN/10.3901/JME.260589

http://www.cjmenet.com.cn/CN/Y2026/V62/I11/61

参考文献

[1] 姚锡凡，景轩，周佳军，等. 走向新一代可持续制造—— 包容性制造[J]. 计算机集成制造系统，2019，25(10)： 2419-2432. YAO Xifan，JING Xuan，ZHOU Jiajun，et al. Towards a new generation of sustainable manufacturing：Inclusive manufacturing[J]. Computer Integrated Manufacturing Systems，2019，25(10)：2419-2432.
[2] TATICCHI P，TONELLI F，PASQUALINO R. Performance measurement of sustainable supply chains[J]. International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management，2013，62(8)：782-804.
[3] 李洪丞，曹华军，刘兰微，等. 碳达峰碳中和背景下低碳制造研究现状与技术路径研究[J]. 机械工程学报，2023，59(7)：225-240. LI Hongcheng，CAO Huajun，LIU Lanwei，et al. Research status and technology path of low-carbon manufacturing under the background of carbon peak and carbon neutrality[J]. Journal of Mechanical Engineering，2023，59(7)：225-240.
[4] 张辰源，陶飞. 数字孪生模型评价指标体系[J]. 计算机集成制造系统，2021，27(8)：2171-2186. ZHANG Chenyuan，TAO Fei. Evaluation index system for digital twin model[J]. Computer Integrated Manufacturing Systems，2021，27(8)：2171-2186.
[5] 王婕，耿秀丽. 基于直觉模糊余弦相似度的云制造服务质量评价[J]. 计算机集成制造系统，2021，27(4)：1128-1134. WANG Jie，GENG Xiuli. Evaluation of cloud manufacturing service quality based on intuitionistic fuzzy cosine similarity[J]. Computer Integrated Manufacturing Systems，2021，27(4)：1128-1134.
[6] ABEDINI A，LI W，BADURDEEN F，et al. A metric- based framework for sustainable production scheduling[J]. Journal of Manufacturing Systems，2020，54：174–185.
[7] 石小秋，李炎炎，邓丁山，等. 基于自适应变级遗传杂草算法的FJSP研究[J]. 机械工程学报，2019，55(6)：223-232. SHI Xiaoqiu，LI Yanyan，DENG Dingshan，et al. Research on FJSP based on adaptive graded genetic weed algorithm[J]. Journal of Mechanical Engineering，2019，55(6)：223-232.
[8] 苏建涛，董绍华，朱诗敏. 多目标混合流水车间机器故障重调度问题研究[J]. 机械工程学报，2024，60(4)：438-448. SU Jiantao，DONG Shaohua，ZHU Shimin. Research on machine fault rescheduling problem in multi-objective mixed flow workshop[J]. Journal of Mechanical Engineering，2024，60(4)：438-448.
[9] LU T. A metrics-based sustainability assessment of cryogenic machining using modeling and optimization of process performance[D]. Lexington：University of Kentucky，2014.
[10] HAPUWATTE B M，BADURDEEN F，JAWAHIR I S. Metrics-based integrated predictive performance models for optimized sustainable product design[J]. Sustainable Design and Manufacturing，2017，68：25-34.
[11] HUANG A，BADURDEEN F. Metrics-based approach to evaluate sustainable manufacturing performance at the production line and plant levels[J]. Journal of Cleaner Production，2018，192：462-476.
[12] MASTROCINQUE E，RAMÍREZ F J，HONRUBIA- ESCRIBANO A，et al. An AHP-based multi-criteria model for sustainable supply chain development in the renewable energy sector[J]. Expert Systems with Applications，2020，150：1-17.
[13] LIN G，ZHANG Q，ZHANG Y，et al. Performance assessment of public transport networks：An AHP-ANP approach[J]. Heliyon，2024，10(22)：e40309.
[14] 孔琳，王黎明，吕晓腾，等. 基于多层级约束满足问题的产品全生命周期设计方案决策研究[J]. 机械工程学报，2023，59(11)：276-289. KONG Lin，WANG Liming，LÜ Xiaoteng，et al. Research on product life cycle design decision based on multi-level constraint satisfaction problem[J]. Journal of Mechanical Engineering，2023，59(11)：276-289.
[15] 刘玲，何玉洁，夏露，等. 基于直觉模糊环境下汽车行业的绿色供应商选择研究[J]. 物流工程与管理，2023，45(1)：1-5. LIU Ling，HE Yujie，XIA Lu，et al. Research on green supplier selection in automotive industry based on intuitionistic ambiguity environment[J]. Logistics Engineering and Management，2023，45(1)：1-5.
[16] 吕淑然，田琦. 基于DEMATEL-ANP-GRA的大型泵站运行安全综合评价[J]. 安全与环境学报，2022，22(4)：1729-1735. LÜ Shuran，TIAN Qi. Comprehensive evaluation of operation safety of large pumping station based on DEMATEL-ANP-GRA[J]. Journal of Safety and Environment，2022，22(4)：1729-1735.
[17] 李达，张普琛，林倪，等. 基于多模型耦合的电动汽车三电系统安全性估计方法[J]. 机械工程学报，2023，59(12)：354-363. LI Da，ZHANG Puchen，LIN Ni，et al. Safety estimation method of electric vehicle three-electric system based on multi-model coupling[J]. Journal of Mechanical Engineering，2023，59(12)：354-363.
[18] NIU Q，ZHOU T，MA S，A quantum-inspired immune algorithm for hybrid flow shop with makespan criterion[J]. Journal of Universal Computer Science，2009，15(4)：765-785.
[19] GONG G L，CHIONG R，DENG Q W，et al. Energy-efficient flexible flow shop scheduling with worker flexibility[J]. Expert Systems with Applications，2020，141：112902.
[20] WANG S，LU Y. A branch and price algorithm for single-machine completion time variance[J]. Computers and Operations Research，2019，109：188-199.
[21] WANG X，LI Z，CHEN Q，et al. Meta-heuristics for unrelated parallel machines scheduling with random rework to minimize expected total weighted tardiness[J]. Computers and Industrial Engineering，2020，145(100)：106505.
[22] WANG J，WANG L. A cooperative memetic algorithm with feedback for the energy-aware distributed flow-shops with flexible assembly scheduling[J]. Computers & Industrial Engineering，2022，168：108126.
[23] SHAO W，SHAO Z，PI D. A network memetic algorithm for energy and labor-aware distributed heterogeneous hybrid flow shop scheduling problem[J]. Swarm and Evolutionary Computation，2022，75：101190.
[24] KHARE A，AGRAWAL S. Scheduling hybrid flowshop with sequence-dependent setup times and due windows to minimize total weighted earliness and tardiness[J]. Computers and Industrial Engineering，2019，135：780-792.
[25] KOUIDER A，BOUZOUIA B. Multi-agent job shop scheduling system based on co-operative approach of idle time minimisation[J]. International Journal of Production Research，2012，50(2)：409-424.
[26] ZHU H，DENG Q，ZHANG L，et al. Low carbon flexible job shop scheduling problem considering worker learning using a memetic algorithm[J]. Optimization and Engineering，2020，21(4)：1691-1716.
[27] GONG G，DENG Q，CHIONG R，et al. Remanufacturing- oriented process planning and scheduling：Mathematical modelling and evolutionary optimization[J]. International Journal of Production Research，2020，58(12)：3781-3799.
[28] GONG X，DE PESSEMIER T，MARTENS L，et al. Energy-and labor-aware flexible job shop scheduling under dynamic electricity pricing：A many-objective optimization investigation[J]. Journal of Cleaner Production，2019，209：1078-1094.
[29] MOKHTARI H，HASANI A. An energy-efficient multi- objective optimization for flexible job-shop scheduling problem[J]. Computers and Chemical Engineering，2017，104：339-352.
[30] SHEIKHALISHAHI M，ESKANDARI N，MASHAYEKHI A，et al. Multi-objective open shop scheduling by considering human error and preventive maintenance[J]. Applied Mathematical Modelling，2019，67：573-587.
[31] GONG X，DENG Q，GONG G，et al. A memetic algorithm for multi-objective flexible job-shop problem with worker flexibility[J]. International Journal of Production Research，2018，56(7)：2506-2522.
[32] HONMA S，HU J L. Cost efficiency of recycling and waste disposal in Japan[J]. Journal of Cleaner Production，2020，284：125274.
[33] FAZLOLLAHTABAR H，MAHDAVI I，ASHOORI M T，et al. A multi-objective decision-making process of supplier selection and order allocation for multi-period scheduling in an electronic market[J]. International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology，2011，52(9-12)：1039-1052.
[34] WANG S，MASON S J，GANGAMMANAVAR H. Stochastic optimization for flow-shop scheduling with on-site renewable energy generation using a case in the United States[J]. Computers and Industrial Engineering，2020，149：106812.
[35] ZANDI A，RAMEZANIAN R，MONPLAISIR L. Green parallel machines scheduling problem：A bi-objective model and a heuristic algorithm to obtain Pareto frontier[J]. Journal of the Operational Research Society，2020，71(6)：967-978.
[36] YIN L，LI X，GAO L，LU C，et al. A novel mathematical model and multi-objective method for the low-carbon flexible job shop scheduling problem[J]. Sustainable Computing：Informatics and Systems，2017，13：15-30.
[37] GUO H，TAN J，LIAO S，et al. Exploring the spatial aggregation and determinants of energy intensity in Guangdong province of China[J]. Journal of Cleaner Production，2021，282：124367.
[38] LUAN B，ZOU H，CHEN S，et al. The effect of industrial structure adjustment on China’s energy intensity：Evidence from linear and nonlinear analysis[J]. Energy，2021，218：119517.
[39] MALINAUSKAITE J，JOUHARA H，EGILEGOR B，et al. Energy efficiency in the industrial sector in the EU，Slovenia，and Spain[J]. Energy，2020，208：118398.
[40] PULLURU S J，AKKERMAN R. Water-integrated scheduling of batch process plants：Modelling approach and application in technology selection[J]. European Journal of Operational Research，2018，269(1)：227-243.
[41] VÁSQUEZ-LAVÍN F，VARGAS O L，HERNÁNDEZ J I，et al. Water demand in the Chilean manufacturing industry：Analysis of the economic value of water and demand elasticities[J]. Water Resources and Economics，2020，32：100159.
[42] PULLURU S J，AKKERMAN R. Data-driven water- efficient production scheduling in the food industry[J]. Computer Aided Chemical Engineering. 2018，43：1063-1068.
[43] ADEKOLA O，MAJOZI T. Wastewater minimization in batch plants with sequence dependent changeover[J]. Computers & Chemical Engineering，2017，97：85-103.
[44] TAN H X，YEO Z，NG R，et al. A sustainability indicator framework for Singapore small and medium-sized manufacturing enterprises[J]. Procedia CIRP，2015，29：132-137.
[45] CAO J，PAN R，XIA X，et al. An efficient scheduling approach for an iron-steel plant equipped with self- generation equipment under time-of-use electricity tariffs[J]. Swarm and Evolutionary Computation，2021，60：100764.
[46] IVERSEN E B，MORALES J M，MØLLER J K，et al. Short-term probabilistic forecasting of wind speed using stochastic differential equations[J]. International Journal of Forecasting，2016，32(3)：981-990.
[47] PIROOZFARD H，WONG K Y，WONG W P. Minimizing total carbon footprint and total late work criterion in flexible job shop scheduling by using an improved multi- objective genetic algorithm[J]. Resources，Conservation and Recycling，2018，128：267-283.
[48] WANG J，YAO S，SHENG J C，et al. Minimizing total carbon emissions in an integrated machine scheduling and vehicle routing problem[J]. Journal of Cleaner Production，2019，229：1004-1017.
[49] MENG X M. Recognition of toxic gases emission in power plant based on artificial neural network[J]. Energy Procedia，2012，17：1578-1584.
[50] LIU C，GAO M，ZHU G，et al. Data driven eco-efficiency evaluation and optimization in industrial production[J]. Energy，2021，224：120170.
[51] KERDSIRI S，ARAMKUL S，CHAMPRASERT P. Fatigue consideration optimization model for employee allocation in flow shop scheduling problems[C]//2019 IEEE 6th International Conference on Industrial Engineering and Applications (ICIEA). IEEE，2019：898-902.
[52] DEMESURE G，CHARPENTIER P，SIADAT A，et al. Jobs scheduling within Industry 4.0 with consideration of worker's fatigue and reliability using greedy randomized adaptive search procedure[J]. IFAC PapersOnLine，2019，52(19)：85-90.
[53] RUIZ-TORRES A J，ABLANEDO-ROSAS J H，MUKHOPADHYAY S，et al. Scheduling workers：A multi-criteria model considering their satisfaction[J]. Computers and Industrial Engineering，2019，128：747-754.
[54] LIU M，LIU X. Satisfaction-driven bi-objective multi-skill workforce scheduling problem[J]. IFAC PapersOnLine，2019，52(13)：229-234.
[55] GENG K，YE C，LIU L. Research on multi-objective hybrid flow shop scheduling problem with dual resource constraints using improved memetic algorithm[J]. IEEE Access，2020，8：104527-104542.
[56] ZHANG Z，TANG Q H，RUIZ R，et al. Ergonomic risk and cycle time minimization for the U-shaped worker assignment assembly line balancing problem：A multi-objective approach[J]. Computers and Operations Research，2020，118：104905.
[57] LIAN J，LIU C G，LI W J，et al. A multi-skilled worker assignment problem in seru production systems considering the worker heterogeneity[J]. Computers and Industrial Engineering，2018，118：366-382.
[58] WU Y，ZENG S，YU Y. Modelling and a hybrid genetic algorithm for the equity-oriented worker assignment problem in seru production systems[J]. Journal of Industrial and Management Optimization，2024，20(1)：36-58.
[59] LEE Y H. The workload assignment problem in consideration of the worker pairing and the workload balancing[J]. Industrial Engineers Interfaces，2009，22(3)：263-277.
[60] BOENZI F，DIGIESI S，MOSSA G，et al. Modelling workforce aging in job rotation problems[J]. IFAC-PapersOnLine，2015，48(3)：604-609.
[61] SOBHANI A，WAHAB M I M，NEUMANN W P. Incorporating human factors-related performance variation in optimizing a serial system[J]. European Journal of Operational Research，2017，257(1)：69-83.
[62] LU C，GAO L，LI X，et al. A multi-objective approach to welding shop scheduling for makespan，noise pollution and energy consumption[J]. Journal of Cleaner Production，2018，196：773-787.
[63] FU Y，TIAN G，FATHOLLAHI-FARD A M，et al. Stochastic multi-objective modelling and optimization of an energy-conscious distributed permutation flow shop scheduling problem with the total tardiness constraint[J]. Journal of Cleaner Production，2019，226：515-525.
[64] LIAO W，FU Y. Min–max regret criterion-based robust model for the permutation flow-shop scheduling problem[J]. Engineering Optimization，2020，52(4)：687-700.