构件不同部位粗糙度对疲劳性能影响差异分析

doi:10.3901/JME.2020.02.043

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 为验证构件不同部位粗糙度影响的差异性，以某型铝合金为研究对象，采用疲劳试验与理论分析相结合的方法分析不同部位粗糙度组合下构件疲劳性能的差异。试验设计中，为区分不同部位粗糙度造成的影响，着重对试样角部、面部和曲面部做不同的表面处理，同时设计棒试样及两类厚度的板试样以说明试验结果的普适性，并在试验结果处理中通过观测试样的断口形貌定义面断裂（曲面断裂）与角断裂两种断裂形式。为进一步定量分析不同部位粗糙度影响差异性的大小，采用有限元软件分析不同部位微缺口附近的应力分布特性，另外，针对本研究的特殊性提出一种适用于微尺寸缺口处应力计算的改进场强法，并采用此方法分别计算试样表面各类微缺口处的有效破坏应力及有效应力集中系数。通过试验结果与理论计算结果对比发现，对于同样表面粗糙度的试样，不同部位微缺口处的有效应力集中系数存在显著差异，即角部微缺口处集中系数明显高于面部，这一结论反映到宏观上表现为试样边角处的粗糙度对试样疲劳性能的影响明显高于试样面部粗糙度的影响，因此传统方法中将两者做等同处理缺乏一定的合理性。

关键词: 铝合金, 粗糙度, 应力集中, 疲劳试验, 场强法

Abstract: In order to verify the difference effect of roughness in different part of structure, taking a certain type of aluminum alloy as the research object, fatigue test and theoretical analysis are used to analyze the difference of fatigue performance under the combination of different roughness. In the test, emphasis is placed on different surface treatment combinations for corner, face and curved face to find the difference between the effects of the roughness of different parts. In addition, bar specimens and two kinds of thickness plate specimens are designed to illustrate the universality of the test results and two fracture forms of plane fracture (surface fracture) and angle fracture are defined by observing the fracture surface of the specimens In the test results processing. Finite element software is used to analyze the stress distribution characteristics near the micro notch of different parts to quantitatively analyze the difference of the roughness of them. For the particularity of this study, an improved field strength method for stress calculation of micro notch is proposed and effective failure stress and effective stress concentration factor at various micro notches on the specimen surface are calculated by this method. By comparing the experimental results with the theoretical results, it is found that there are significant differences in effective stress concentration coefficient at different locations, which means the concentration coefficient at the corner microgap is obviously higher than that of the face, for the sample with the same surface roughness. This conclusion is reflected in the macroscopic view that the roughness at the corner of the specimen has a greater effect on the fatigue performance of the specimen than the roughness of the specimen surface, which means it is not reasonable to treat them equally in traditional way.

Key words: aluminum alloy, roughness, stress concentration, fatigue test, field intensity method

中图分类号:

O346

赵丙峰, 谢里阳, 李冲, 王博文, 秦波. 构件不同部位粗糙度对疲劳性能影响差异分析[J]. 机械工程学报, 2020, 56(2): 43-55.

ZHAO Bingfeng, XIE Liyang, LI Chong, WANG Bowen, QIN Bo. Analysis on the Different Effect of Roughness in Different Part of Structure on Fatigue Property[J]. Journal of Mechanical Engineering, 2020, 56(2): 43-55.

参考文献

[1] WANG Jinlong,ZHANG Yuanliang,SUN Qingchao,et al. Giga-fatigue life prediction of FV520B-I with surface roughness[J]. Materials & Design,2016,89:1028-1034.
[2] 宋波,章媛洁,赵晓,等. 激光选区熔化增材与机加工复合制造AISI 420不锈钢:表面粗糙度与残余应力演变规律研究[J]. 机械工程学报,2018,54(13):170-178. SONG Bo,ZHANG Yuanjie,ZHAO Xiao,et al. Selective Laser melting and subtractive hybrid manufacture AISI420 stainless steel:Evolution on surface roughness and residual stress[J]. Journal of Mechanical Engineering,2018,54(13):170-178.
[3] PU Wei,ZHU Dong,WANG Jiaxu,et al. Rolling-sliding contact fatigue of surfaces with sinusoidal roughness[J]. International Journal of Fatigue,2016,90:57-68.
[4] JONES J L,MCMURTREY M D,BROWN L B,et al. The effect of crack wake roughness on the environmentally assisted fatigue behavior of an aerospace Al-alloy in low moisture environments[J]. Engineering Fracture Mechanics,2018,199:343-357.
[5] 刘军,刘勇俊,刘永寿,等. 开孔试样的表面粗糙度对疲劳寿命影响的定量分析[J]. 中国机械工程,2008,19(3):327-329. LIU Jun,LIU Yongjun,LIU Yongshou,et al. Quantitative analysis of roughness effect on fatigue life of specimen with open holes[J]. China Mechanical Engineering,2008,19(3):327-329.
[6] SILVA P S C P D,CAMPANELLI L C,CLAROS C A E,et al. Prediction of the surface finishing roughness effect on the fatigue resistance of Ti-6Al-4V ELI for implants applications[J]. International Journal of Fatigue,2017,103:258-263.
[7] WANG Jinlong,ZHANG Yuanliang,ZHAO Qingchen,et al. The fatigue failure analysis and fatigue life prediction model of FV520B-I as a function of surface roughness in HCF regime[J]. Journal of Materials Research,2017,32(3):634-643.
[8] HATAMLEH O,LYONS J,FORMAN R. Laser peening and shot peening effects on fatigue life and surface roughness of friction stir welded 7075-T7351 aluminum[J]. Fatigue & Fracture of Engineering Materials & Structures,2010,30(2):115-130.
[9] BAGEHORN S,WEHR J,MAIER H J. Application of mechanical surface finishing processes for roughness reduction and fatigue improvement of additively manufactured Ti-6Al-4V parts[J]. International Journal of Fatigue,2017,102:135-142.
[10] LI Changyou,DAI Weibing,DUAN Fei,et al. Fatigue life estimation of medium-carbon steel with different surface roughness[J]. Applied Sciences,2017,7(4):338.
[11] LACERDA J C D,MARTINS G D,SIGNORETTI V T,et al. Corrigendum to "evolution of the surface roughness of a low carbon steel subjected to fatigue"[J]. International Journal of Fatigue,2017,102:143-148.
[12] MEREUTA V,BUCIUMEANU M,PALAGHIAN L. 3D roughness parameters as factors in determining the evolution of effective stress concentration factors in fatigue processes[J]. Applied Mechanics & Materials,2013,248(1):504-510.
[13] KYAW S T,ROUSE J P,LU J,et al. Effects of surface roughness on thermo-mechanical fatigue life of a P91 power plant steel[J]. Procedia Structural Integrity,2016,2:664-672.
[14] AMOR M B,BELGHITH S,MEZLINI S. Finite element modeling of RMS roughness effect on the contact stiffness of rough surfaces[J]. Tribology in Industry,2016,38(3):392-401.
[15] ANDREWS S,SEHITOGLU H. A computer model for fatigue crack growth from rough surfaces[J]. International Journal of Fatigue,2000,22(7):619-630.
[16] 廖智奇,吴运新,袁海洋. 表面粗糙度对三维应力集中系数及疲劳寿命的影响[J]. 中国机械工程,2015,26(2):147-151. LIAO Zhiqi,WU Yunxin,YUAN Haiyang. Influences of surface roughness on three dimensional stress concentration factor and fatigue life[J]. China Mechanical Engineering,2015,26(2):147-151.
[17] MISRA A,PANDEY P M,DIXIT U S. Modeling and simulation of surface roughness in ultrasonic assisted magnetic abrasive finishing process[J]. International Journal of Mechanical Sciences,2017,133:344-356.
[18] AROLA D,WILLIAMS C L. Estimating the fatigue stress concentration factor of machined surfaces[J]. International Journal of Fatigue,2002,24(9):923-930.
[19] EMBRECHTS J J. The random-incidence scattering coefficient of infinite periodic surfaces with rectangular and sine-shaped roughness profiles[C/CD]//Forum Acusticum,Aalborg,Denmark. 2011.
[20] 程正坤,廖日东,李玉婷,等. 表面形貌对应力集中系数的影响研究[J]. 北京理工大学学报,2016,36(3):231-236. CHENG Zhengkun,LIAO Ridong,LI Yuting,et al. Effect of surface topography on stress concentration factor[J]. Transactions of Beijing Institute of Technology,2016,36(3):231-236.
[21] SURARATCHAI M,LIMIDO J,MABRU C,et al. Modelling the influence of machined surface roughness on the fatigue life of aluminium alloy[J]. International Journal of Fatigue,2008,30(12):2119-2126.
[22] ALANG N A,RAZAK N A,MISKAM A K. Effect of surface roughness on fatigue life of notched carbon steel[J]. International Journal of Engineering & Technology,2011,11(1):160-163.
[23] ALENCAR G,JESUS A M P D,RUI A B C,et al. Fatigue life evaluation of a composite steel-concrete roadway bridge through the hot-spot stress method considering progressive pavement deterioration[J]. Engineering Structures,2018,166:46-61.
[24] GAUR V,ENOKI M,OKADA T,et al. A study on fatigue behavior of MIG-welded Al-Mg alloy with different filler-wire materials under mean stress[J]. International Journal of Fatigue,2018,10:119-129.
[25] ZHAO Bingfeng,XIE Liyang,BAI Xin,et al. A multi-axial low-cycle fatigue life prediction model considering effects of additional hardening[J]. Fatigue & Fracture of Engineering Materials & Structures,2018,41(7):1488-1503.
[26] YADOLLAHI A,MAHTABI M J,KHALILI A,et al. Fatigue life prediction of additively manufactured material:effects of surface roughness,defect size,and shape[J]. Fatigue & Fracture of Engineering Materials & Structures,2018,41(7):1602-1614.
[27] HAGHSHENAS A,KHONSARI M M. Damage accumulation and crack initiation detection based on the evolution of surface roughness parameters[J]. International Journal of Fatigue,2018,107:130-144.
[28] BIAN Xinxiao,LI Wei,QIU Lifang. Study on C-R-S curves of up-and-down test and fatigue limit stress[J]. Journal of University of Science & Technology Beijing,2010,32(3):380-383.
[29] BAI Xin,XIE Liyang,ZHANG Ruijin,et al. Measurement and estimation of probabilistic fatigue limits using Monte-Carlo simulations[J]. International Journal of Fatigue,2017,95:229-235.
[30] 尚德广,王大康,李明,等. 随机疲劳寿命预测的局部应力应变场强法[J]. 机械工程学报,2002,38(1):67-70. SHANG Deguang,WANG Dakang,LI Ming,et al. Method of local stress-strain fieid intensity for random fatigue life prediction[J]. Chinese Journal of Mechanical Engineering,2002,38(1):67-70.
[31] YAO Weixing,YE Bin,ZHENG Lichun. A verification of the assumption of anti-fatigue design[J]. International Journal of Fatigue,2001,23(3):271-277.
[32] LIU Gang,TANG Liulun,HUANG Yi. A study on the influence factors of fatigue in welded joints based on field inten-sity approach[J]. Journal of Ship Mechanics,2014,18(1):158-164.
[33] WANG Mingchun,SONG Enpeng,ZHAO Qinghua. The prediction of mutiaxial high cycle fatigue based on stress field in-tensity[J]. Aircraft Design,2015,35(4):10-13.