硬质涂层冲击、冲蚀性能的研究进展

doi:10.3901/JME.2017.24.012

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 工程领域中随处可见的碰撞、振动现象，使冲击和冲蚀已成为众多装备中关键零部件破坏和失效的主要原因之一。表面工程特别是涂层技术的发展和应用有效地改善了这一情况，通过赋予材料表面更好的性能，延长了工件的使用寿命。涂层的冲击磨损和冲蚀磨损不仅与材料有关，还受到角度、温度等服役工况的影响，是一个多因素共同作用的复杂过程。通本文以硬质涂层为对象，介绍了其发展历程，分析并总结了其耐冲击、冲蚀性能的研究现状，并展望了未来研究趋势。

关键词: 表征手段, 冲击磨损, 冲蚀磨损, 试验设备, 硬质涂层

Abstract: Impacts and vibrations are common in the engineering fields, which leads the impact wear and erosion wear become one of the prime reasons for the destruction and failure of key components. The development and application of surface engineering technologies, especially the surface coating technology, effectively improve this situation, resulting in a prolonged service life by giving better performance on the material surface. The impact wear and erosion wear of coatings are not only depended on materials, but also affected by the angle, temperature and other service conditions, which is a complex process of multiple factors. Experimental studies are usually used to obtain reliable data and results, and the development of test device is briefly introduced, as well as the characterization methods of impact performance. The future research trends of the impact and erosion behavior of hard coating are also prospected.

Key words: characterization method, erosion, hard coatings, impact wear, test device

中图分类号:

TH117

蔡振兵, 王璋, 朱旻昊. 硬质涂层冲击、冲蚀性能的研究进展[J]. 机械工程学报, 2017, 53(24): 12-24.

CAI Zhenbing, WANG Zhang, ZHU Minhao. Review on Impact and Erosion Wear Research of Hard Coatings[J]. Journal of Mechanical Engineering, 2017, 53(24): 12-24.

参考文献

[1] 徐滨士. 表面工程新技术[M]. 北京:国防工业出版社,2002. XU Binshi. New technology of surface engineering[M]. Beijing:National Defense Industry Press,2002.
[2] 薛群基,王立平. 类金刚石碳基薄膜材料[M]. 北京:科学出版社,2012. XUE Qunji,WANG Liping. Thin film materials of carbon-base DLC[M]. Beijing:Science Press,2012.
[3] HAUERT R. A review of modified DLC coatings for biological applications[J]. Diamond & Related Materials,2003,12(3-7):583-589.
[4] MAURER C,SCHULZ U. Erosion resistant titanium based PVD coatings on CFRP[J]. Wear,2013,302(s1-2):937-945.
[5] 夏光明,周建桥,闵小兵,等. 涂层技术概述及工程应用[J]. 金属材料与冶金工程,2012,40(1):53-59. XIA Guangming,ZHOU Jianqiao,MIN Xiaobing,et al. Overview on coating technology and its engineering application[J]. Metal Materials and Metallurgy Engineering,2012,40(1):53-59.
[6] TRAPEZON A G,LYASHENKO B A,LYSENKOV M O. Fatigue strength of metals with hardening coatings[J]. Strength of Materials,2013,45(3):284-294.
[7] SIDKY P S,HOCKING M G. Review of inorganic coatings and coating processes for reducing wear and corrosion[J]. British Corrosion Journal,1999,34(3):171-183.
[8] MO J L,ZHU M H,LEYLAND A,et al. Impact wear and abrasion resistance of CrN,AlCrN and AlTiN PVD coatings[J]. Surface & Coatings Technology,2013,215(4):170-177.
[9] CASSAR G,BANFIELD S,WILSON A B,et al. Impact wear resistance of plasma diffusion treated and duplex treated/PVD-coated Ti-6Al-4V alloy[J]. Surface & Coatings Technology,2012,206(10):2645-2654.
[10] 吴凤芳. PVD氮化物涂层的冲蚀磨损特性及机理的研究[D]. 济南:山东大学,2011. WU Fengfang. Research on the erosion characteristics and wear mechanisms of nitride coatings[D]. Jinan:Shandong University,2011.
[11] CAI F,HUANG X,YANG Q. Mechanical properties,sliding wear and solid particle erosion behaviors of plasma enhanced magnetron sputtering CrSiCN coating systems[J]. Wear,2015,324-325:27-35.
[12] KUPTSOV K A,KIRYUKHANTSEV-KORNEEV P V,SHEVEYKO A N,et al. Comparative study of electrochemical and impact wear behavior of TiCN,TiSiCN,TiCrSiCN,and TiAlSiCN coatings[J]. Surface & Coatings Technology,2013,216(216):273-281.
[13] WIECIŃSKI P,SMOLIK J,GARBACZ H,et al. Erosion resistance of the nanostructured Cr/CrN multilayer coatings on Ti6Al4V alloy[J]. Vacuum,2014,107(18):277-283.
[14] CHANG Y Y,WU C J. Mechanical properties and impact resistance of multilayered TiAlN/ZrN coatings[J]. Surface & Coatings Technology,2013,231(9):62-66.
[15] FENG C,JIANG S. Cavitation erosion resistance of diamond-like carbon coating on stainless steel[J]. Applied Surface Science,2014,292(3):16-26.
[16] WELLMAN R G,NICHOLLS J R. Erosion,corrosion and erosion-corrosion of EB PVD thermal barrier coatings[J]. Tribology International,2008,41(7):657-662.
[17] SHANOV V,TABAKOFF W,METWALLY M. Erosive wear of CVD ceramic coatings exposed to particulate flow[J]. Surface & Coatings Technology,1992,54-55(9):25-31.
[18] SHANOV V,SINGH R N,TABAKOFF W. CVD diamond coating for erosion protection at elevated temperatures[J]. Journal of Materials Engineering and Performance,2002,11(2):220-225.
[19] BHUSHAN B,BHUSHAN B. Modern tribology handbook[M]. Boca Raton:CRC Press,2001.
[20] KULU P,HUSSAINOVA I,VEINTHAL R. Solid particle erosion of thermal sprayed coatings[J]. Wear,2005,258(1-4):488-496.
[21] 姚梦佳,李春福,何俊波,等. 抗冲蚀磨损涂层的研究进展[J]. 材料导报,2015(s2):283-286. YAO Mengjia,LI Chunfu,HE Junbo,et al. Progresses of anti-erosion coatings[J]. Materials Review,2015(s2):283-286.
[22] 刘成龙,林英英,王玥霁,等. 金属材料表面抗空蚀涂层的研究进展[J]. 材料导报,2011,25(1):127-131. LIU Chenglong,LIN Yingying,WANG Yueji,et al. Progress in coatings on the surface of metals for anti-cavitation corrosion[J]. Materials Review,2011,25(1):127-131.
[23] THAKUR L,ARORA N,JAYAGANTHAN R,et al. An investigation on erosion behavior of HVOF sprayed WC-CoCr coatings[J]. Applied Surface Science,2011,258(3):1225-1234.
[24] HONG S,WU Y,ZHANG J,et al. Effect of ultrasonic cavitation erosion on corrosion behavior of high-velocity oxygen-fuel (HVOF) sprayed near-nanostructured WC-10Co-4Cr coating[J]. Ultrasonics Sonochemistry,2015,27:374-378.
[25] DALLAIRE S. Hard arc-sprayed coating with enhanced erosion and abrasion wear resistance[J]. Journal of Thermal Spray Technology,2001,10(3):511-519.
[26] IRISSOU E,DADOUCHE A,LIMA R S. Tribological characterization of plasma-sprayed CoNiCrAlY-BN abradable coatings[J]. Journal of Thermal Spray Technology,2014,23(1-2):252-261.
[27] PRAVEEN A S,SARANGAN J,SURESH S,et al. Erosion wear behaviour of plasma sprayed NiCrSiB/Al₂O₃,composite coating[J]. International Journal of Refractory Metals & Hard Materials,2015,52:209-218.
[28] LI X Z,WANG Y T,XU G,et al. Thick Ni based amorphous composite coating with good erosion wear resistance[J]. Material Research Innovations,2015,18(S4):S4-777-S4-781.
[29] ARENSBURGER D S,ZIMAKOV S Y,KULU P A. Coatings deposited by the high-velocity flame spraying method[J]. Powder Metallurgy & Metal Ceramics,2001,40(3-4):127-134.
[30] 李太江,李巍,李勇,等. 超音速火焰喷涂制备NiCr金属陶瓷涂层的抗高温硫腐蚀与冲蚀磨损性能[J]. 中国电机工程学报,2012,32(20):120-125. LI Taijiang,LI Wei,LI Yong,et al. Performance of HVOF NiCr cermets coating against high temperature sulfur corrosion and erosion[J]. Proceedings of the Chinese Society for Electrical Engineering,2012,32(20):120-125.
[31] YASIR M,ZHANG C,WANG W,et al. Enhancement of impact resistance of Fe-based amorphous coating by Al₂O₃,dispersion[J]. Materials Letters,2016,171:112-116.
[32] 李国禄,李楠楠,王海斗,等. 不同喷涂工艺制备的Al₂O₃-13%TiO₂涂层表面自由能与冲蚀磨损性能研究[J]. 机械工程学报,2016,52(10):59-66. LI Guolu,LI Nannan,WANG Haidou,et al. Research on surface free energy and erosion wear property of Al₂O₃-13%TiO₂ coatings prepared by different spraying processes[J]. Journal of Mechanical Engineering,2016,52(10):59-66.
[33] 庞佑霞,许焰,张昊,等. 微/纳米复合涂层的抗冲蚀磨损性能[J]. 材料工程,2013(9):60-63. PANG Youxia,XU Yan,ZHANG Hao,et al. Erosion resistance of micro/nano composite coating[J]. Journal of Materials Engineering,2013(9):60-63.
[34] 杨静,周永生,李良锋,等. 氯化橡胶涂层冲蚀磨损行为的研究[J]. 摩擦学学报,2016,36(1):110-116. YANG Jing,ZHOU Yongsheng,LI Liangfeng,et al. Slurry erosion wear behaviors of chlorinated rubber paint[J]. Tribology,2016,36(1):110-116.
[35] 张荣,马颖,郝远. 等离子体电解沉积表面技术及其发展[J]. 材料导报,2008,22(s3):156-159. ZHANG Rong,MA Ying,HAO Yuan. Plasma electrolytic deposition technology and its development[J]. Materials Review,2008,22(s3):156-159.
[36] 张世欣,刘仁,王小成,等. 铝基体上等离子体电解氧化陶瓷涂层的冲蚀性能[J]. 金属热处理,2015,40(9):84-87. ZHANG Shixin,LIU Ren,WANG Xiaocheng,et al. Erosion performance of plasma electrolytic oxidation ceramic coating on aluminum substrate[J]. Heat Treatment of Metals,2015,40(9):84-87.
[37] CHEN Y,CHENG T,NIE X. Wear failure behaviour of titanium-based oxide coatings on a titanium alloy under impact and sliding forces[J]. Journal of Alloys & Compounds,2013,578(6):336-344.
[38] BAYER R G,ENGEL P A,SIRICO J L. Impact wear testing machine[J]. Wear,1972,19(3):343-354.
[39] BAYER R G,ENGEL P A,SACHER E. Impact wear phenomena in thin polymer films[J]. Wear,1975,32(2):181-194.
[40] ANTONOV M,HUSSAINOVA I,SERGEJEV F,et al. Assessment of gradient and nanogradient PVD coatings behaviour under erosive,abrasive and impact wear conditions[J]. Wear,2009,267(5-8):898-906.
[41] ABDOLLAH M F B,YAMAGUCHI Y,AKAO T,et al. Deformation-wear transition map of DLC coating under cyclic impact loading[J]. Wear,2012,s274-275(3):435-441.
[42] ABDOLLAH M F B. Future developments of a deformation-wear transition map of DLC coating[J]. Tribology Online,2012,7(3):107-111.
[43] SARLIN E,APOSTOL M,LINDROOS M,et al. Impact properties of novel corrosion resistant hybrid structures[J]. Composite Structures,2014,108:886-893
[44] LINDROOS M,APOSTOL M,KUOKKALA V T,et al. Experimental study on the behavior of wear resistant steels under high velocity single particle impacts[J]. International Journal of Impact Engineering,2015,78:114-127.
[45] SATO Y,IWABUCHI A,UCHIDATE M,et al. Dynamic corrosion properties of impact-fretting wear in high-temperature pure water[J]. Wear,2015,s330-331:182-192.
[46] LIN Y W,CAI Z B,CHEN Z Q,et al. Influence of diameter-thickness ratio on alloy Zr-4 tube under low-energy impact fretting wear[J]. Materials Today Communications,2016,8:79-90.
[47] 王璋,蔡振兵,孙阳,等. 基于冲击动能控制的Cr-DLC涂层动力学响应和磨损行为[J]. 中国表面工程,2017,30(4):78-86. WANG Zhang,CAI Zhenbing,SUN Yang,et al. Dynamic response and wear behavior of Cr-DLC coating under impact kinetic energy controlled mode[J]. China Surface Engineering,2017,30(4):78-86.
[48] WANG Z,CAI Z B,SUN Y,et al. Low velocity impact wear behavior of MoS₂/Pb nanocomposite coating under controlled kinetic energy[J]. Surface & Coatings Technology,2017,326:53-62.
[49] 王璋,蔡振兵,孙阳,等. 纯铁在球/面接触下的冲击微动磨损行为研究[J]. 摩擦学学报,2017,37(2):225-232. WANG Zhang,CAI Zhenbing,SUN Yang,et al. Impact fretting wear behavior of pure iron under ball-to-flat contact[J]. Tribology,2017,37(2):225-232.
[50] CAI Z B,GUAN H D,CHEN Z Q,et al. Impact fretting wear behavior of 304 stainless steel thin-walled tubes under low-velocity[J]. Tribology International,2017,105:219-228.
[51] SUN Y,CAI Z B,CHEN Z Q,et al. Impact fretting wear of Inconel 690 tube with different supporting structure under cycling low kinetic energy[J]. Wear,2017,s376-377:625-633.
[52] GUAN H D,CAI Z B,REN Y P,et al. Impact-fretting wear behavior of Inconel 690 alloy tubes effected by pre-compressive stress[J]. Journal of Alloys and Compounds,2017,724:910-920.
[53] STRONGE W J,YU T X. Dynamic models for structural plasticity[M]. London:Springer,1993.
[54] 邱自学,袁江. 落锤式冲击试验机及其多参数测试系统[J]. 电子测量与仪器学报,2006,20(1):52-55. QIU Zixue,YUAN Jiang. Drop weight impact tester and its measuring system for multi-parameters[J]. Journal of Electronic Measurement and Instrumentation,2006,20(1):52-55.
[55] 姜祎,刘明,杜令忠,等. 热喷涂涂层结合强度的冲击测量法[J]. 中国表面工程,2017,30(3):131-138. JIANG Yi,LIU Ming,DU Lingzhong,et al. Evaluation of impact indentation adhesion test of thermal spray coatings[J]. China Surface Engineering,2017,30(3):131-138.
[56] AL-MOUSAWI M M,REID S R,DEANS W F. The use of the split Hopkinson pressure bar techniques in high strain rate materials testing[J]. Journal of Mechanical Engineering Science,1997,211(4):273-292.
[57] SHIM J,MOHR D. Using split Hopkinson pressure bars to perform large strain compression tests on polyurea at low,intermediate and high strain rates[J]. International Journal of Impact Engineering,2009,36(9):1116-1127.
[58] 索涛,邓琼,苗应刚,等. 基于Hopkinson压杆实验技术的含能材料动态力学性能测试方法研究进展[J]. 火炸药学报,2010,33(2):5-9. SUO Tao,DENG Qiong,MIAO Yinggang,et al. Progress in experimental determination of dynamic mechanical behaviors of energetic materials based on split hopkinson pressure bar[J]. Chinese Journal of Explosives & Propellants,2010,33(2):5-9.
[59] 马峰,蔡珣. 膜基界面结合强度表征和评价[J]. 表面技术,2001,30(5):15-19. MA Feng,CAI Xun. Characterization and evaluation of the interfacial bond strength between coating and substrate[J]. Surface Technology,2001,30(5):15-19.
[60] CHALKER P R,BULL S J,RICKERBY D S. A review of the methods for the evaluation of coating-substrate adhesion[J]. Materials Science & Engineering A,1991,140(91):583-592.
[61] 杨金霞. 基体拉伸法测试膜基界面结合力的研究[D]. 天津:天津大学,2007. YANG Jinxia. Study on interface bonding strength between films and substrates by substrate straining method[D]. Tianjin:Tianjin University,2007.
[62] TING B Y,RAMALINGAM S,WINER W O. An experimental investigation of the film-to-substrate bond strength of sputtered thin film using a semi-quantitative test method[J]. Journal of Tribology,1985,107(4):478-482.
[63] 郑小玲,游敏. 拉伸法测定涂层界面强度的适用性研究[J]. 粘接,2003,24(2):7-9. ZHENG Xiaoling,YOU Min. The adaptability of tensile method in determination of interfacial strength of coating layer and metal substrate[J]. Adhesion,2003,24(2):7-9.
[64] MARSHALL D B,LAWN B R,EVANS A G. Elastic/plastic indentation damage in ceramics:The lateral crack system[J]. Journal of the American Ceramic Society,1980,63(9-10):574-581.
[65] HUTCHINSON J W,SUO Z. Mixed mode cracking in layered materials[J]. Advances in Applied Mechanics,1991,29(8):63-191.
[66] VLASSAK J J,DRORY M D,NIX W D. A simple technique for measuring the adhesion of brittle films to ductile substrates with application to diamond-coated titanium[J]. Journal of Materials Research,1997,12(12):1900-1910.
[67] KRIESE M D,GERBERICH W W,MOODY N R. Quantitative adhesion measures of multilayer films:Part Ⅱ. Indentation of W/Cu,W/W,Cr/W[J]. Journal of Materials Research,1999,14(7):3007-3018.
[68] 李坤明,包亦望,万德田,等. 压痕法和十字交叉法评价类金刚石硬质涂层的界面结合强度[J]. 硅酸盐学报,2010,38(1):119-125. LI Kunming,BAO Yiwang,WAN Detian,et al. Interfacial bonding strength of diamond-like carbon coating using indentation and cross-bonded methods[J]. Journal of the Chinese Ceramic Society,2010,38(1):119-125.
[69] 冯爱新,张永康,谢华琨,等. 划痕试验法表征薄膜涂层界面结合强度[J]. 江苏大学学报,2003,24(2):15-19. FENG Aixin,ZHANG Yongkang,XIE Huakun,et al. Characterization of interfacial adhesion and bond strength between thin film coating and substrate by scratch testing[J]. Journal of Jiangsu University,2003,24(2):15-19.
[70] BURNETT P J,RICKERBY D S. The scratch adhesion test:An elastic-plastic indentation analysis[J]. Thin Solid Films,1988,157(2):233-254.
[71] BULL S J,BERASETEGUI E G. Chapter 7-An overview of the potential of quantitative coating adhesion measurement by scratch testing[J]. Tribology & Interface Engineering,2006,51(2):136-165.
[72] RANDALL N X,FAVARO G,FRANKEL C H. The effect of intrinsic parameters on the critical load as measured with the scratch test method[J]. Surface & Coatings Technology,2001,137(2):146-151.
[73] 中华人民共和国机械工业部. JB/T8554-1997,气相沉积薄膜与基体附着力的划痕试验法[S]. 北京:机械科学研究院,1997. Ministry of Machinery and Industry of the People' Republic of China. JB/T8554-1997,Scratch test method for adhesion between vapor deposition films and substrates[S]. Beijing:Institute of Mechanical Science,1997.
[74] 石宗利,黄元林,王彦平,等. Ag-Cu/Ti纳米双层膜结合强度测试方法研究[J]. 实验力学,2002,17(2):170-176. SHI Zongli,HUANG Yuanlin,WANG Yanping,et al. A study on the testing methods of the adhesion strength of Ag-Cu/Ti nano-bilayer film system[J]. Journal of Experimental Mechanics,2002,17(2):170-176.
[75] BOUZAKIS K D,CHARALAMPOUS P,SKORDARIS G,et al. Fatigue and adhesion characterization of DLC coatings on steel substrates by perpendicular and inclined impact tests[J]. Surface & Coatings Technology,2015,275:207-213.
[76] LAWES S D A,HAINSWORTH S V,FITZPATRICK M E. Impact wear testing of diamond-like carbon films for engine valve-tappet surfaces[J]. Wear,2010,268(11):1303-1308.
[77] 王艳,周仲荣. 钛合金表面非平衡磁控溅射制备TiN薄膜的冲击磨损性能[J]. 中国表面工程,2010,23(4):7-10. WANG Yan,ZHOU Zhongrong. Impact wear performance of TiN film grown on Ti alloys by unbalanced magnetron sputtering[J]. China Surface Engineering,2010,23(4):7-10.
[78] 石世宏,傅戈雁,李婷,等. 激光涂层及多冲后的组织结构变化[J]. 中国机械工程,2005,16(11):1005-1008. SHI Shihong,FU Geyan,LI Ting,et al. Organization variety of laser cladding layer under repeated impact load[J]. China Mechanical Engineering,2005,16(11):1005-1008.
[79] MANHABOSCO T M,MÜLLER I L. Tribocorrosion of diamond-like carbon deposited on Ti6Al4V[J]. Tribology Letters,2009,33(3):193-197.
[80] ZHOU L Y,ZHANG H,PEI X Q,et al. Erosive wear of transparent nanocomposite coatings[J]. Tribology International,2013,61(61):62-69.
[81] LAGUNA-CAMACHO J R,MÁRQUEZ-VERA C A,PATIÑO-VALDEZ A A,et al. A study of the erosive wear damage on a recycled polymer coating[J]. Wear,2015,s332-333:836-843.
[82] BOUZAKIS K D,ASIMAKOPOULOS A,SKORDARIS G,et al. The inclined impact test:A novel method for the quantification of the adhesion properties of PVD films[J]. Wear,2007,262(11-12):1471-1478.
[83] BOUZAKIS K D,ASIMAKOPOULOS A,MICHAILIDIS N,et al. The inclined impact test,an efficient method to characterize coatings' cohesion and adhesion properties[J]. Thin Solid Films,2004,s469-470(1):254-262.
[84] KIM G S,LEE S Y,HAHN J H,et al. Effects of the thickness of Ti buffer layer on the mechanical properties of TiN coatings[J]. Surface & Coatings Technology,2002,171(1-3):83-90.
[85] 何光宇,李应红,柴艳,等. 航空发动机压气机叶片砂尘冲蚀防护涂层关键问题综述[J]. 航空学报,2015,36(6):1733-1743. HE Guangyu,LI Yinghong,CHAI Yan,et al. Review of key issues on coating against sand erosion of aero-engine compressor blade[J]. Acta Aeronautica ET Astronautica Sinica,2015,36(6):1733-1743.
[86] BORAWSKI B,SINGH J,TODD J A,et al. Multi-layer coating design architecture for optimum particulate erosion resistance[J]. Wear,2011,271(11):2782-2792.
[87] BORAWSKI B,TODD J A,SINGH J,et al. The influence of ductile interlayer material on the particle erosion resistance of multilayered TiN based coatings[J]. Wear,2011,271(11-12):2890-2898.
[88] BOUZAKIS K D,VIDAKIS N,LEYENDECKER T,et al. Determination of the fatigue behaviour of thin hard coatings using the impact test and a FEM simulation[J]. Surface & Coatings Technology,1996,s86-87(96):549-556.
[89] BOUZAKIS K D,SIGANOS A,LEYENDECKER T,et al. Thin hard coatings fracture propagation during the impact test[J]. Thin Solid Films,2004,460(1-2):181-189.