Nano-mechanical Degradation Behavior and Mechanism of Ag/Ti2SnC Composite Electrical Contact Materials During Arc Erosion

doi:10.3901/JME.2024.24.163

Abstract

Abstract: Silver-based electrical contact is a key material for structural-functional integration of low-voltage electrical equipment. In the actual service process, the maintenance of material composition-mechanical properties is the key to resist arc erosion and avoid premature failure of electrical contact materials. Therefore, elucidation of the degradation law of nano-mechanical properties at different arc erosion stages can further enrich the mechanism of electrical contact, which is of great significance for developing new electrical contact materials and advancing the innovation of low-voltage switch materials. In this study, Ag/Ti₂SnC electrical contact material samples with different arc erosion times were designed, and nanoindentation techniques (static indentation, creep, continuous stiffness, NanoBlitz 3D indentation)were used to systematically analyze the nanomechanical properties of the section near the arc erosion area. Our results indicated a gradual degradation in the nano-mechanical properties of the samples with increasing arc erosion times, although the rate of this degradation appeared to decelerate over arc erosion times. During the early (1～100 times)and intermediate (100～1000 times)stages of arc erosion, the decline in the nano-mechanical properties was primarily due to the decomposition of Ti₂SnC and limited surface oxidation. During the later stages of arc erosion (1000～6200 times), even though Ti₂SnC damage from the surface to the inside, the formation of a surface oxidation layer and Ag-Sn interdiffusion behavior effectively slowed the mechanical property degradation, enabling Ag/Ti₂SnC to maintain good arc erosion resistance. This study delivers an insightful nano-mechanical perspective on the arc erosion resistance of Ag/Ti₂SnC electrical composite contact materials, providing a solid theoretical base for future material system continued design and optimization.

Key words: MAX phase, silver-based composite electrical contact, nano-mechanical behavior, material microstructure, arc erosion mechanism

CLC Number:

TG148
TM286

WEI Xinpeng, WU Xuelian, WU Chengzhe, SUN Wanjie, DING Jianxiang, BAI Xiaoping, LIU Dongming, ZHANG Shihong, REN Wanbin, SUN Zhengming. Nano-mechanical Degradation Behavior and Mechanism of Ag/Ti2SnC Composite Electrical Contact Materials During Arc Erosion[J]. Journal of Mechanical Engineering, 2024, 60(24): 163-176.

References

[1] KESIM M T，YU H，SUN Y，et al. Corrosion，oxidation，erosion and performance of Ag/W-based circuit breaker contacts：A review[J]. Corrosion Science，2018，135：12-34.
[2] LI Shibo，BEI Guoping，CHEN Xiaodong，et al. Crack healing induced electrical and mechanical properties recovery in a Ti₂SnC ceramic[J]. Journal of the European Ceramic Society，2016，36(1)：25-32.
[3] 李玲玲，韩俊杰，王成山. 基于灰色理论的继电器电接触可靠性预测[J]. 机械工程学报，2012，48(2)：68-72.LI Linging，HAN Junjie，WANG Chengshan. Based on grey theory of prediction on electrical contact reliability of relay[J]. Journal of Mechanical Engineering，2012，48(2)：68-72.
[4] 李玲玲，马东娟，李志刚. 基于状态监测数据的电器电接触性能评估[J]. 机械工程学报，2015，51(18)：198-203.LI Lingling，MA Dongjuan，LI Zhigang. Performance assessment based on condition monitoring data of electrical contact of electrical products[J]. Journal of Mechanical Engineering，2015，51(18)：198-203.
[5] MYSHKIN N K，BRAUNOVICH M，KONCHITS V V. The mechanics and tribophysics of electrical contacts[J]. Journal of Friction and Wear，2015，36(6)：454-467.
[6] WU Qiong，XU Guofu，YUAN Meng，et al. Influence of operation numbers on arc erosion of Ag/CdO electrical contact materials[J]. IEEE Transactions on Components，Packaging and Manufacturing Technology，2020，10(5)：845-857.
[7] TEIXEIRA F，PERES A，GOMES T，et al. A review on the applicability of life cycle assessment to evaluate the technical and environmental properties of waste electrical and electronic equipment[J]. Journal of Polymers and the Environment，2021，29(5)：1333-1349.
[8] HUANG Runzhang，XU Guofu，WU Qiong，et al. Influence of operation number on arc erosion behavior of Ag/Ni electrical contact materials[J]. Transactions of Nonferrous Metals Society of China，2022，32(8)：2681-2695.
[9] SUN Zhengming. Progress in research and development on MAX phases：a family of layered ternary compounds[J]. International Materials Reviews，2011，56(3)：143-166.
[10] 张辉，王晓辉，周延春. MAX相中的晶体结构缺陷：研究现状与发展方向[J]. 现代技术陶瓷，2019，40：150-173.ZHANG Hui，WANG Xiaohui，ZHOU Yanchun. Crystal defects in MAX phases：The current status and future directions[J]. Advanced Ceramics，2019，40：150-173.
[11] 江涛. 三元层状结构MAX相陶瓷材料的制备技术及其研究发展现状和发展趋势[J]. 现代技术陶瓷，2023，44：1-23.JIANG Tao. Fabrication technology，research and development status，development trend of the ternary laminated structure MAX phase ceramics materials[J]. Advanced Ceramics，2023，44：1-23.
[12] 孙正明，丁健翔，张培根，等. 一种高纯度Ti₂SnC粉体的制备方法：中国，CN105777127A[P]. 2016-07-20.SUN Zhengming，DING Jianxiang，ZHANG Peigen，et al. A preparation method of high purity Ti₂SnC powder：China，CN105777127A[P]. 2016-07-20.
[13] DING Jianxiang，ZHANG Kaige，LIU Dongming，et al. Ag-based electrical contact material reinforced by Ti₃AlC₂ ceramic and its derivative Ti₃C₂T_x[J]. Journal of Inorganic Materials，2022，37(5)：567-573.
[14] WANG Dandan，TIAN Wubian，DING Jianxiang，et al. Anisotropic arc erosion resistance of Ag/Ti3AlC2 composites induced by the alignment of Ti3AlC2[J]. Corrosion Science，2020，171：108633.
[15] DING Kuankuan，ZHANG Kaige，DING Jianxiang，et al. Effect of Al atomic layer on the wetting behavior，interface structure and electrical contact properties of silver reinforced by Ti₃AlC₂ ceramic[J]. Ceramics International，2022，48(1)：190-198.
[16] DING Jianxiang，HUANG Peiyan，ZHA Yuhui，et al. High-purity Ti₂AlC powder：Preparation and application in Ag-based electrical contact materials[J]. Journal of Inorganic Materials，2020，35(6)：729-734.
[17] ZHANG Kaige，DING Jianxiang，DING Kuankuan，et al. Evolution of phases，microstructure，and physical properties of Ti₂AlC-reinforced Ag-matrix composites with elevated fabrication temperature[J]. Journal of Materials Engineering and Performance，2023，32(9)：4270-4282.
[18] SUN Wanjie，SHI Yuxin，WU Chengzhe，et al. Insights into nano-mechanical degradation behavior of Ag/Ti₂AlC composite under different arc erosion stages[J]. Journal of Materials Research and Technology，2023，27：1968-1981.
[19] ZHOU Zijue，FENG Yi，ZHAO Hao，et al. Arc erosion behavior and mechanism of Ag/Ti₃SiC₂ cathodes in different atmospheres[J]. Ceramics International，2021，47(2)：2319-2328.
[20] WANG Dandan，TIAN Wubian，LU Chengjie，et al. Comparison of the interfacial reactions and properties between Ag/Ti₃AlC₂ and Ag/Ti₃SiC₂ electrical contact materials[J]. Journal of Alloys and Compounds，2021，857：157588.
[21] HUANG Xiaochen，FENG Yi，GE Jinling，et al. Arc erosion mechanism of Ag-Ti₃SiC₂ material[J]. Journal of Alloys and Compounds，2020，817：152741.
[22] DING Jianxiang，TIAN Wubian，WANG Dandan，et al. Microstructure evolution，oxidation behavior and corrosion mechanism of Ag/Ti₂SnC composite during dynamic electric arc discharging[J]. Journal of Alloys and Compounds，2019，785：1086-1096.
[23] DING Jianxiang，TIAN Wubian，ZHANG Peigen，et al. Preparation and arc erosion properties of Ag/Ti₂SnC composites under electric arc discharging[J]. Journal of Advanced Ceramics，2019，8(1)：90-101.
[24] 丁宽宽，丁健翔，张凯歌，等. 多场耦合侵蚀下环保Ag/Ti₂SnC复合电接触材料的微/纳米力学行为及微结构演变[J]. 金属学报，2024，60(12)：1731-1745.DING Kuankuan，DING Jianxiang，ZHANG Kaige，et al. Micro/nano-mechanical behavior and microstructure evolution of eco-friendly Ag/Ti₂SnC composite electrical contacts under multi-field coupled erosion[J]. Acta Metallurgica Sinca，2024，60(12)：1731-1745.
[25] 丁健翔，夏欣欣，张凯歌，等. 不同制备温度下Ti₂SnC增强银基复合材料的物相、微观组织和物理性能演变[J]. 材料导报，2023，37(16)：5-12.DING Jianxiang，XIA Xinxin，ZHANG Kaige，et al. Evolution of phase，microstructure and physical properties of Ti₂SnC-reinforcing Ag-based composite with elevated preparing temperature[J]. Meterials Reports，2023，37(16)：5-12.
[26] 丁健翔，孙正明. Ag/MAX复合电触头材料的制备与性能研究[D]. 南京：东南大学，2018.DING Jianxiang，SUN Zhengming. Preparation and properties of Ag/MAX composite electrical contact materials[D]. Nanjing：Southeast University，2018.
[27] DING Kuankuan，DING Jianxiang，ZHANG Kaige，et al. Micro/nano-mechanical properties evolution and degradation mechanism of Ti₃AlC₂ ceramic reinforced Ag-based composites under high-temperature arc corrosion[J]. Ceramics International，2022，48(22)：33670-33681.
[28] DOERNER M F，NIX W D. A method for interpreting the data from depth-sensing indentation instruments[J]. Journal of Materials Research，1986，1(4)：601-609.
[29] OLIVER W C，PHARR G M. An improved technique for determining hardness and elastic modulus using load and displacement sensing indentation experiments[J]. Journal of Materials Research，1992，7(6)：1564-1583.
[30] 黎明，温诗铸. 纳米压痕技术理论基础[J]. 机械工程学报，2003，39(3)：142-145.LI Ming，WEN Shizhu. Theoretical methods on nanoindentation[J]. Journal of Mechanical Engineering，2003，39(3)：142-145.
[31] 徐连勇，张舒婷，荆洪阳，等. Ag-GNSs/SnAgCu钎料纳米压痕变形行为研究[J]. 机械工程学报，2018，54(8)：151-156.XU Lianyong，ZHANG Shuting，JING Hongyang，et al. Research on the deformation behavior of Ag-GNSs/ SnAgCu solders during nanoindentation tests[J]. Journal of Mechanical Engineering，2018，54(8)：151-156.
[32] IM S，JEE H，SUH H，et al. Insight on the mechanical properties of hierarchical porous calcium-silicate-hydrate pastes according to the Ca/Si molar ratio using in-situ synchrotron X-ray scattering and nanoindentation test[J]. Construction and Building Materials，2023，365：130034.
[33] YAN Cong，BOR B，PLUNKETT A，et al. Nanoindentation creep of supercrystalline nanocomposites[J]. Materials & Design，2023，231：112000.
[34] LI Mingjing，SCHEIDER I，BOR B，et al. Ultra-thin and ultra-strong organic interphase in nanocomposites with supercrystalline particle arrangement：Mechanical behavior identification via multiscale numerical modeling[J]. Composites Science and Technology，2020，198：108283.
[35] TANG Jingwen，ZHANG Peigen，LIU Yushuang，et al. Selective growth of tin whiskers from its alloys on Ti₂SnC[J]. Journal of Materials Science & Technology，2020，54：206-210.
[36] OLIVER W C，PHARR G M. Measurement of hardness and elastic modulus by instrumented indentation：Advances in understanding and refinements to methodology[J]. Journal of Materials Research，2004，19(1)：3-20.
[37] 周甜，蔡力勋，韩光照. 用于延性材料力学性能测定的圆柱平面-小冲杆试验新方法与应用[J]. 机械工程学报，2024，60(4)：316-325.ZHOU Tian，CAI Lixun，HAN Guangzhao. Novel Flat-SPT method for obtaining mechanical properties of ductile materials and its application[J]. Journal of Mechanical Engineering，2024，60(4)：316-325.
[38] ZHANG Jingfeng，GADELMEIER C，SEN S，et al. Zr diffusion in BCC refractory high entropy alloys：A case of ‘non-sluggish’ diffusion behavior[J]. Acta Materialia，2022，233：117970.
[39] WANG Yizhou，WANG Yunjiang. Disentangling diffusion heterogeneity in high-entropy alloys[J]. Acta Materialia，2022，224：117527.
[40] ZHONG Cheng，LIU Fan，WU Yating，et al. Protective diffusion coatings on magnesium alloys：A review of recent developments[J]. Journal of Alloys and Compounds，2012，520：11-21.
[41] HU Chuanlin，YAO Shun，ZOU Fubing，et al. Insights into the influencing factors on the micro-mechanical properties of calcium-silicate-hydrate gel[J]. Journal of the American Ceramic Society，2019，102(4)：1942-1952.
[42] WEI Hongming，LI Mingchao，ZOU Jianpeng，et al. Study on sintering process of Ti₂SnC modified copper- graphite composites[J]. Vacuum，2023，209：111813.
[43] ZHANG Xu，ZHENG Zhe，REN Wanbin，et al. An experimental investigation of dynamic welding mechanism of contacts used in low current switching devices[C]//2018 IEEE Holm Conference on Electrical Contacts. IEEE，2018：488-494.
[44] CHEN Siyu，WANG Jun，YUAN Zhao，et al. Microstructure and arc erosion behaviors of Ag-CuO contact material prepared by selective laser melting[J]. Journal of Alloys and Compounds，2021，860：158494.
[45] WU Chunping，ZHAO Qian，LI Nana，et al. Influence of fabrication technology on arc erosion of Ag/10SnO₂ electrical contact materials[J]. Journal of Alloys and Compounds，2018，766：161-177.
[46] QIU Yanru，WANG Xianhui，LIANG Yan，et al. Arc erosion behavior and mechanism of AgZrO₂ electrical contact materials[J]. Journal of Alloys and Compounds，2024，976：172966.
[47] LI Hangyu，WANG Xianhui，GUO Xiuhua，et al. Material transfer behavior of AgTiB₂ and AgSnO₂ electrical contact materials under different currents[J]. Materials & Design，2017，114：139-148.