Analysis and Optimization of Residual Stress after Reflow Soldering of BGA Lead Free Solder Joints

doi:10.3901/JME.2020.10.086

Abstract

Abstract: A finite element model of residual stress after reflow soldering of lead free BGA solder joints is established, and analyzed the residual stress after reflow soldering under the structure-thermal coupling conditions. The deterministic experiment is designed and completed based on the Hole drilling strain-gauge method. The significance and the order of the influence of solder joint height, solder joint diameter, pad diameter and solder joint pitch on the residual stress of solder joints are analyzed based on the sensitivity method. Setting the factors that have significant influence on residual stress are variable, and then the structural parameters of solder joints are optimized by response surface method and genetic algorithm. The results show that the deterministic experiment results verify the effectiveness of the simulation analysis results. The significant factors for the residual stress are the solder joint diameter, solder joint pitch and solder joint height when the confidence is 95%, and the order of sensitivity from large to small is solder joint diameter, solder joint diameter and solder joint height. The optimal structure parameter combination of the solder joint of the minimum residual stress after reflow soldering is that solder joint diameter of 0.55 mm, the solder joint height of 0.36 mm and the solder joint pitch of 1.07 mm.The simulation results of the solder joint show that the maximum residual stress decreased 0.998 MPa.The research results have certain guiding significance and reference value for reducing the residual stress after reflow soldering of BGA solder joints.

Key words: ball grid array, reflow soldering, residual stress, sensitivity analysis, response surface, genetic algorithm

CLC Number:

TG404

ZHAO Shengjun, HUANG Chunyue, LIANG Ying, KUANG Bing, TANG Xiangqiong. Analysis and Optimization of Residual Stress after Reflow Soldering of BGA Lead Free Solder Joints[J]. Journal of Mechanical Engineering, 2020, 56(10): 86-94.

References

[1] 张翼,薛齐文,王云峰. 微电子封装的发展历史和新动态[J]. 机械工程与自动化,2016,2(1):215-216. ZHANG Yi,XUE Qiwen,WANG Yunfeng. Development history and new development of microelectronic packa-ging[J]. Mechanical Engineering & Automation,2016,2(1):215-216.
[2] 蒋延彪,田刚领,杨道国,等. PBGA器件固化残余应力的有限元分析[J]. 电子元件与材料,2005,24(2):3-6. JIANG Yanbiao,TIAN Gangling,YANG Daoguo,et al. Finite element simulation analysis on cure-residual stress in PBGA device[J]. Electronic Components & Materials,2005,24(2):3-6.
[3] 田艳红,贺晓斌,杭春进. 残余应力对混合组装BGA热循环可靠性影响[J]. 机械工程学报,2014,50(2):86-91. TIAN Yanhong,HE Xiaobin,HANG Chunjin. Influence of the hybrid BGA residual stress after reflow on the thermal cycling reliability[J]. Journal of Mechanical Engineering,2014,50(2):86-91.
[4] 钟开少,代宣军. 无铅BGA回流焊残余应力仿真分析[J]. 装备制造技术,2014,2(10):44-46. ZHONG Kaishao,DAI Xuanjun. BGA lead-free reflow residual stress simulation analysis[J]. Equipment Manu-facturing Technology. 2014,2(10):44-46.
[5] SAKAI H,YAMAOKA N. Shape prediction and residual stress evaluation of BGA and flip chip solder joints[J]. Thermal and Thermomechanical Phenomena in Electronic Systems,2000:181-186.
[6] UETA N,SASAKI T,MIURA H. Proposal of area-arrayed bump joint structures for minimizing residual stress in stacked silicon chips mounted by flip chip technology[J]. Electronic Materials and Packaging,2008:228-231.
[7] XU Yaowu. Residual stress evaluation in welded large thin-walled structures based on eigenstrain analysis and small sample residualstress measurement[J]. Thin-Walled Structures,2018,1(31):782-791.
[8] 甘世明,韩永全,陈芙蓉. 钻孔法测量焊接残余应力误差因素分析[J]. 焊接学报,2018,39(10):48-53. GAN Shiming,HAN Yongquan,CHEN Furong. Analysis on error factors of welding residual stress measured by hole drilling method[J]. Transactions of the China Welding Institution,2018,39(10):48-53.
[9] 李响铸. 基于ANSYS软件PDS模块机械零件状态函数灵敏度分析[D]. 长春:吉林大学,2006. LI Xiangzhu. Function of state sensitivity analysis of mechanical part based on ANSYS of PDS module[D]. Changchun:Jilin University,2006.
[10] PARK J U,AN G. The effect of initial stress induced during the steel manufacturing process on the welding residual stress in multi-pass butt welding[J]. International Journal of Naval Architectureand Ocean Engineering,2018,10(2):129-140.
[11] MOHAMMAD A G. Reliability analysis of vibrating electronic assemblies using analytical solutions and response surface methodology[J]. Microelectronics Reliability,2018,8(4):238-247.
[12] VOTI R L. Optimization of a perfect absorber multilayer structure by genetic algorithms[J]. Journal of the European Optical Society-Rapid Publications,2018,14(1):11-15.

[1]	CHEN Zhaojie, XIE Jin, LIU Junhan, XIONG Changxin, LI Difan. Study on Impulse-discharge Driven Abrasive Flow Assisted Grinding of Monocrystalline SiC [J]. Journal of Mechanical Engineering, 2024, 60(9): 383-392.
[2]	SHI Qin, JIANG Zhengxin, LIU Yiwen, WEI Yujiang, HU Xiaosong, HE Lin. Fractional Order Model-based Estimation for State of Charge in Lithium-ion Battery [J]. Journal of Mechanical Engineering, 2024, 60(8): 224-232,244.
[3]	CHENG Hongxin, LI Luyi, ZHOU Changcong. Method for Sensitivity Analysis of the Uncertain Distribution Parameters Based on Kriging Model and Surrogate Sampling [J]. Journal of Mechanical Engineering, 2024, 60(8): 370-383.
[4]	WANG Yuefei, WANG Chao, XU Yutao, SUN Rui, XIAO Kai, WANG Kailin. Digital Twin Task Scheduling Method for Jobs of Intelligent Manufacturing Unit under Edge-cloud Collaboration [J]. Journal of Mechanical Engineering, 2024, 60(6): 137-152.
[5]	ZHAO Ping, ZHANG Yating, CHENG Yue, XU Hongwei, ZI Bin. Multi-task Trajectory Synthesis Method of Single-DOF Stephenson Mechanisms Based on Sensitivity Analysis [J]. Journal of Mechanical Engineering, 2024, 60(5): 59-69.
[6]	WEI Yongqiao, ZHANG Jin, WANG Shaojiang, QI Xiaohu, GUO Rui, YANG Haijiang. Wear and Sensitivity Analysis of Transmission Interface of Cylindrical Gear with Variable Hyperbolic Circular-arc-tooth-trace [J]. Journal of Mechanical Engineering, 2024, 60(5): 81-94.
[7]	HU Long, LIU Hongyan, CHENG Huimei, CHEN Weiqi, FENG Guangjie, YE Yanhong, DENG Dean. Study on Residual Stress of Multi-layer and Multi-pass Butt-welded Joint for Ultra-high Strength Wear-resistant Steel NM500 [J]. Journal of Mechanical Engineering, 2024, 60(4): 335-344.
[8]	MA Yongtao, SUN Ning, WANG Junlong, LI Chunfan, LU Chunsheng, ZHANG Bin, LIU Lanrong. Calculation of Shot Peening Coverage of Pre-mixed Jet and its Influence on the Surface Integrity of Carburized Steel [J]. Journal of Mechanical Engineering, 2024, 60(3): 393-404.
[9]	QIN Tao, LI Yunhua, FAN Rujun. Trajectory Optimization of Autonomous Mining for Powerful Rocker Arm Hydraulic Shovels [J]. Journal of Mechanical Engineering, 2024, 60(18): 374-384.
[10]	YUAN Ye, YANG Huaiguang, DING Liang, LAN Qingning, YANG Chaojie, GAO Haibo, DENG Zongquan. Experimental Study and Modeling Considering the Influence of Wheel Load for Planetary Exploration Rovers [J]. Journal of Mechanical Engineering, 2024, 60(14): 263-271.
[11]	LIU Chengshang, CHEN Rui, LI Fang, WANG Meng, XU Wujiao. Parameters Determination of Hardening Model for Ultra-high Strength Steel Based on Modified Genetic Algorithm and Bending Spring Back Prediction [J]. Journal of Mechanical Engineering, 2024, 60(12): 240-249.
[12]	LU Qi, SU Kaixin, ZHANG Jiwang, YAN Tao, YANG Bing, ZHANG Haonan. Structural Optimization of Simple Catenary Based on BP Neural Network and Genetic Algorithm [J]. Journal of Mechanical Engineering, 2024, 60(12): 313-320.
[13]	ZHANG Guang-dong, HUANG Xiang. Optimization Design Method of Plastic Extrusion Die for Product Geometric Accuracy [J]. Journal of Mechanical Engineering, 2023, 59(8): 142-150.
[14]	LIU Hao, CHEN Zhengying, SHEN Kai, XIONG Xuhui. Normal Vector Optimization Technology of Five-axis FDM Cladding Path Based on Minimum AC Rotation Angle Change [J]. Journal of Mechanical Engineering, 2023, 59(6): 272-284.
[15]	ZHANG Jiyin, YAO Changfeng, TAN Liang, CUI Minchao, ZHOU Zheng, SUN Yunqi, LI Guoxi, FAN Yi. Research Progress of the Effect of Shot Peening Residual Stress on Fatigue Performance and Deformation Control [J]. Journal of Mechanical Engineering, 2023, 59(6): 46-60.