Research Progress on Metal Rubber Material as a Foundational Component for Vibration Reduction：A Review

doi:10.3901/JME.2024.24.104

Abstract

Abstract: Metal rubber materials, composed of a metal matrix and porous elastic damping material, possess a combination of high elasticity and large damping properties of rubber, along with excellent physical and mechanical properties of metal matrix materials. As a key vibration-reduction component in high-end equipment, this material holds significant potential for application. However, the intricate fabrication process and disordered internal structure make it challenging to establish a clear mapping relationship between the material's microscopic structure and macroscopic performance, thus limiting the optimization and industrial application of this material. This work provides a comprehensive overview of the current status and advancements in the research of metal rubber materials, both domestically and internationally. It sequentially discusses the fabrication process, digital measurement and modeling techniques, research status of performance characterization theory, and engineering applications of metal rubber materials. The focus is on the unique mechanical and physical properties of metal rubber and how these properties are influenced by their internal structure and actual working conditions. The aim is to gain a comprehensive understanding of the latest research progress and future development trends in this metal-based porous damping material.

Key words: metal rubber, foundational component, performance characterization, fabrication process, damping and vibration reduction

CLC Number:

TH161

SHI Linwei, REN Zhiying, HUANG Zihao, DU Pengcheng, LIU Tianyan. Research Progress on Metal Rubber Material as a Foundational Component for Vibration Reduction：A Review[J]. Journal of Mechanical Engineering, 2024, 60(24): 104-126.

References

[1] 李贵军，王乐勤，郑传祥. 高温设备和构件的蠕变损伤和断裂研究进展[J]. 化工机械，2004(2)：119-124. LI Guijun, WANG Leqin, ZHENG Chuanxiang. Progress in creep damage and fracture of high-temperature equipment and components[J]. Chemical Machinery，2004(2)：119-124.
[2] 张有华. 高压机械密封的设计与应用[J]. 流体机械，2005(2)：5-8. ZHANG Youhua. Design and application of high-pressure mechanical seals[J]. Fluid Machinery，2005(2)：5-8.
[3] CARRASCAL I A，PÉREZ A，CASADO J A，et al. Experimental study of metal cushion pads for high-speed railways[J]. Construction and Building Materials，2018，182：1-10.
[4] Hadden S，Davis T，Buchele P，et al. Heavy load vibration isolation system for airborne payloads[C]//Smart Structures and Materials 2001：Industrial and Commercial Applications of Smart Structures Technologies. SPIE，2001，4332：171-182.
[5] 切戈达耶夫. 金属橡胶构件的设计[M]. 李中郢，译. 北京：国防工业出版社，2000. CHEGODAYEV. Design of metal rubber components[M]. Translated by LI Zhongyi. Beijing：National Defense Industry Press，2000.
[6] GADOT B，RIU M O，ROLLAND D S，et al. Entangled single-wire NiTi material：a porous metal with tunable superelastic and shape memory properties[J]. Acta Materialia，2015，96(1)：311-323.
[7] CHANDRASEKHAR K，RONGONG J，CROSS E. Mechanical behaviour of tangled metal wire devices[J]. Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing，2019，118(1)：13-29.
[8] XUE Xin，RUAN Shixing，BAI Hongbai，et al. An enhanced constitutive model for the nonlinear mechanical behavior of the elastic-porous metal rubber [J]. Mechanics of Materials，2020，148(1)：103447.
[9] 陈建烨. 金属橡胶减振特性研究及在发动机管路中的应用[D]. 哈尔滨：哈尔滨工业大学，2017. CHEN Jianye. Study on the vibration damping characteristics of metal rubber and its application in engine pipelines [D]. Harbin：Harbin Institute of Technology，2017.
[10] 李拓，白鸿柏，路纯红，等. 金属橡胶的研究进展及其应用[J]. 新技术新工艺，2013(3)：85-90. LI Tuo，BAI Hongbai，LU Chunhong，et al. Research progress and application of metal rubber[J]. New Technology and New Process，2013(3)：85-90.
[11] ZHU Yue，WU Yiwang，BAI Hongbai，et al. Research on vibration reduction design of foundation with entangled metallic wire material under high temperature[J]. Shock and Vibration，2019(4)：1-16.
[12] 李拓，白鸿柏，路纯红. 金属橡胶复合材料的低频吸声性能[J]. 机械工程材料，2017，41(7)：39-42. LI Tuo，BAI Hongbai，LU Chunhong. Low frequency sound absorption performance of metal rubber composite material[J]. Materials for Mechanical Engineering，2017，41(7)：39-42.
[13] 白鸿柏，詹智强，任志英. 金属橡胶声学性能研究进展与展望[J]. 振动与冲击，2020，39(23)：242-254. BAI Hongbai，ZHAN Zhiqiang，REN Zhiying. Research progress and prospect of acoustic performance of metal rubber[J]. Journal of Vibration and Shock，2020，39(23)：242-254.
[14] 姚伟. 金属橡胶密封件失效模型及性能退化研究[D]. 哈尔滨：哈尔滨工业大学，2017. YAO Wei. Study on failure model and performance degradation of metal rubber seals[D]. Harbin：Harbin Institute of Technology，2017.
[15] 陈祺鑫，黄伟，任志英，等. 大环径比O形金属橡胶密封件的疲劳力学特性及试验研究[J]. 摩擦学学报，2021，41(3)：293-303. CHEN Qixin，HUANG Wei，REN Zhiying，et al. Fatigue mechanical properties and experimental study of large aspect ratio O-ring metal rubber seals[J]. Tribology，2021，41(3)：293-303.
[16] YANG Yu，REN Zhiying，ZHAO Siyang，et al. One-step fabrication of thermal resistant，corrosion resistant metal rubber for oil/water separation[J]. Colloids and Surfaces A：Physicochemical and Engineering Aspects，2019，573：157-164.
[17] REN Zhiying，WEN Gang，GUO Zhiguang. Biomimetic high-intensity superhydrophobic metal rubber with anti- corrosion property for industrial oil-water separation[J]. New Journal of Chemistry，2019，43(4)：1894-1899.
[18] REN Zhiying，Huang Jingfei，BAI Hongbai，et al. Potential application of entangled porous titanium alloy metal rubber in artificial lumbar disc prostheses[J]. Journal of Bionic Engineering，2021，18：584-599.
[19] 王少纯，邓宗全，高海波，等. 月球着陆器用金属橡胶高低温力学性能试验研究[J]. 航空材料学报，2004(2)：27-31. WANG Shaochun，DENG Zongquan，GAO Haibo，et al. Experimental study on high and low temperature mechanical properties of metal rubber for lunar lander[J]. Journal of Aeronautical Materials，2004(2)：27-31.
[20] Ning S K，Jia L，MA B J. Optimization model of metal rubber buffer on artillery[J]. Applied Mechanics and Materials，2013，271：237-241.
[21] 林臻，李国璋，白鸿柏，等. 金属橡胶在模拟海洋环境中的腐蚀行为及阻尼性能[J]. 机械工程材料，2014，38(10)：69-73. LIN Zhen，LI Guozhang，BAI Hongbai，et al. Corrosion behavior and damping performance of metal rubber in simulated marine environment[J]. Materials for Mechanical Engineering，2014，38(10)：69-73.
[22] 周涛，贾地，高晟耀，等. 舰艇高温管路热振耦合试验系统研制[J]. 计算机测量与控制，2021，29(5)：139-140. ZHOU Tao，JIA Di，GAO Shengyao，et al. Development of a thermal-vibration coupling test system for high- temperature pipelines on ships[J]. Computer Measurement & Control，2021，29(5)：139-140.
[23] 孙杨，昌敏，白俊强. 变形机翼飞行器发展综述[J]. 无人系统技术，2021，4(3)：65-77. SUN Yang，CHANG Min，BAI Junqiang. Review on the development of morphing wing aircraft[J]. Unmanned Systems Technology，2021，4(3)：65-77.
[24] 白鸿柏. 金属橡胶材料及工程应用[M]. 北京：科学出版社，2014. BAI Hongbai. Metal rubber materials and engineering applications[M]. Beijing：Science Press，2014.
[25] 卢成壮，李静媛，周邦阳，等. 金属丝特性对金属橡胶疲劳性能的影响[J]. 振动与冲击，2018，37(24)：137-142. LU Chengzhuang，LI Jingyuan，ZHOU Bangyang，et al. Effect of metal wire characteristics on the fatigue performance of metal rubber[J]. Vibration and Shock，2018，37(24)：137-142.
[26] 李拓，白鸿柏，路纯红. 金属橡胶复合材料的低频吸声性能[J]. 机械工程材料，2017，41(7)：39-42. LI Tuo，BAI Hongbai，LU Chunhong. Low frequency sound absorption performance of metal rubber composite material[J]. Materials for Mechanical Engineering，2017，41(7)：39-42.
[27] 唐显鹏，孟庆利，冯浩. SMA金属橡胶阻尼器的减振性能及其在防高墩桥梁地震碰撞中的应用[J]. 西南科技大学学报，2016，31(3)：59-62. TANG Xianpeng，MENG Qingli，FENG Hao. Vibration damping performance of SMA metal rubber damper and its application in preventing seismic collision of high pier bridges[J]. Journal of Southwest University of Science and Technology，2016，31(3)：59-62.
[28] 赵程，罗昆，刘长红. 小丝径65Mn金属橡胶疲劳性能研究[J]. 噪声与振动控制，2010，30(1)：106-108. ZHAO Cheng，LUO Kun，LIU Changhong. Fatigue performance study of small diameter 65Mn metal rubber[J]. Noise and Vibration Control，2010，30(1)：106-108.
[29] 郝慧荣，白鸿柏，张慧杰. 非圆截面丝金属橡胶与普通金属橡胶阻尼性能比较[J]. 机械科学与技术，2009，28(2)：210-213. HAO Huirong，BAI Hongbai，ZHANG Huijie. Comparative study on the damping performance of non-circular section wire metal rubber and ordinary metal rubber[J]. Mechanical Science and Technology，2009，28(2)：210-213.
[30] 陈亚，白鸿柏，路纯红. 金属橡胶制造应用及产品标准化的构建[J]. 现代制造工程，2014(5)：131-135. CHEN Ya，BAI Hongbai，LU Chunhong. Manufacturing application and standardization construction of metal rubber[J]. Modern Manufacturing Engineering，2014(5)：131-135.
[31] 梁倩倩. 金属橡胶螺旋卷成型工艺及机构研究[D]. 西安：西安工业大学，2014. LIANG Qianqian. Study on spiral winding forming process and mechanism of metal rubber[D]. Xi’an：Xi’an Technological University，2014.
[32] 刘红，白鸿柏，郝慧荣. 金属橡胶螺旋卷制备工艺中张力在线测试[J]. 新技术新工艺，2008(9)：93-95. LIU Hong，BAI Hongbai，HAO Huirong. Tension online testing in metal rubber spiral winding preparation process[J]. New Technology and New Process，2008(9)：93-95.
[33] 杨建春，曹凤利，白鸿柏，等. 金属橡胶用螺旋卷拉伸质量控制技术研究[J]. 中国材料科技与设备，2011，7(6)：43-45. YANG Jianchun，CAO Fengli，BAI Hongbai，et al. Study on quality control technology of metal rubber spiral coil stretching[J]. China Materials Science and Technology & Equipment，2011，7(6)：43-45.
[34] 夏宇宏，姜洪源，敖宏瑞，等. 簧丝走向对金属橡胶构件性能的影响分析[J]. 中国机械工程，2002(10)： 76-79. XIA Yuhong，JIANG Hongyuan，AO Hongrui，et al. Analysis of the impact of spring wire direction on the performance of metal rubber components[J]. Chinese Mechanical Engineering，2002(10)：76-79.
[35] 李明森，张文群，吴新跃，等. 金属橡胶自动成型工艺研究[J]. 机械制造. 2009，47(5)：55-57. LI Mingsen，ZHANG Wenqun，WU Xinyue，et al. Research on automatic forming process of metal rubber[J]. Machinery Manufacturing，2009，47(5)：55-57.
[36] 朱育权，周立博，马保吉. 金属橡胶毛坯自动铺设工艺研究[J]. 机械研究与应用，2016，29(2)：78-80. ZHU Yuquan，ZHOU Libo，MA Baoji. Research on automatic laying process of metal rubber blank[J]. Mechanical Research & Application，2016，29(2)：78-80.
[37] REN Zhiying，SHEN Liangliang，BAI Hongbai，et al. Study on the mechanical properties of metal rubber with complex contact friction of spiral coils based on virtual manufacturing technology[J]. Advanced Engineering Materials，2020，22(8)：2000382.
[38] XUE Xin，YANG Pei，SHAO Yichuang，et al. Manufacture technology and anisotropic behaviour of elastic-porous metal rubber[J]. International Journal of Lightweight Materials and Manufacture，2020，3(2)：88-99.
[39] 黄凯，白鸿柏，路纯红，等. 金属橡胶毛坯铺设路径规划[J]. 航空动力学报，2016，31(1)：40-48. HUANG Kai，BAI Hongbai，LU Chunhong，et al. Path planning for metal rubber blank laying[J]. Journal of Aerospace Power，2016，31(1)：40-48.
[40] SHI Linwei，REN Zhiying，HUANG Zhaohua，et al. Research on trajectory optimization of multilateral thin metal rubber automatic laying based on virtual fabrication technology[J]. Advanced Engineering Materials，2022，24(2)：2100754.
[41] 黄凯，白鸿柏，路纯红，等. 复杂构型金属橡胶毛坯铺设路径规划[J]. 航空动力学报，2018，33(7)：1575-1583. HUANG Kai，BAI Hongbai，LU Chunhong，et al. Path planning for complex configuration metal rubber blank laying[J]. Journal of Aerospace Power，2018，33(7)：1575-1583.
[42] 杨建春. 金属橡胶材料制备、多尺度表征及工程应用研究[D]. 北京：北京科技大学，2010. YANG Jianchun. Study on preparation，multi-scale characterization，and engineering application of metal rubber materials[D]. Beijing：University of Science and Technology Beijing，2010.
[43] 曹凤利. 金属橡胶制备工艺及力学性能表征研究[D]. 石家庄：军械工程学院，2014. CAO Fengli. Study on preparation process and mechanical property characterization of metal rubber[D]. Shijiazhuang：Ordnance Engineering College，2014.
[44] 曹凤利，白鸿柏，李国璋，等. 回火对金属橡胶力学性能及宏观结构尺寸的影响[J]. 热加工工艺，2014，43(8)：189-191. CAO Fengli，BAI Hongbai，LI Guozhang，et al. Effect of tempering on mechanical properties and macroscopic structure size of metal rubber[J]. Hot Working Technology，2014，43(8)：189-191.
[45] 杨建春，刘国权，董秀萍，等. 回火对Cr-Ni-Mn不锈钢丝微观组织和性能的影响[J]. 热加工工艺，2011，40(8)：175-177. YANG Jianchun，LIU Guoquan，DONG Xiuping，et al. Effect of tempering on microstructure and properties of Cr-Ni-Mn stainless steel wire[J]. Hot Working Technology，2011，40(8)：175-177.
[46] 赵程，王丽萍，李响. 退火工艺参数对金属橡胶阻尼性能的影响[J]. 热加工工艺，2012，41(16)：192-193. ZHAO Cheng，WANG Liping，LI Xiang. Influence of annealing process parameters on the damping performance of metal rubber[J]. Hot Working Technology，2012，41(16)：192-193.
[47] 赵程，罗昆，李响. 304、65Mn金属橡胶退火工艺参数比较[J]. 热加工工艺，2011，40(14)：93-94. ZHAO Cheng，LUO Kun，LI Xiang. Comparison of annealing process parameters of 304 and 65Mn metal rubber[J]. Hot Working Technology，2011，40(14)：93-94.
[48] 罗昆，赵程，李响. 304MR去应力退火工艺参数优化评价方法探讨[J]. 热加工工艺，2012，41(18)：223-224. LUO Kun，ZHAO Cheng，LI Xiang. Discussion on optimization evaluation method of stress relief annealing process parameters for 304MR[J]. Hot Working Technology，2012，41(18)：223-224.
[49] 侯军芳，刘振广，白鸿柏，等. 基于电脉冲放电烧结工艺的金属橡胶材料电阻特性试验研究[J]. 机械科学与技术，2006，25(6)：753-756. HOU Junfang，LIU Zhenguang，BAI Hongbai，et al. Experimental study on the electrical resistance characteristics of metal rubber materials based on electrical discharge sintering process[J]. Mechanical Science and Technology，2006，25(6)：753-756.
[50] 付海龙，戴光，邹龙庆，等. 金属橡胶表面沉积镍基纳米TiN复合镀层的研究[J]. 表面技术，2011，40(1)：90-92，99. FU Hailong，DAI Guang，ZOU Longqing，et al. Research on nickel-based nano-TiN composite coating deposited on metal rubber surface[J]. Surface Technology，2011，40(1)：90-92，99.
[51] LIU P，HE G，WU L H. Fabrication of sintered steel wire mesh and its compressive properties[J]. Materials Science and Engineering：A，2008，489(1)：21-28.
[52] 李明森，吴新跃，张文群，等. 金属橡胶的角锥模型及有限元分析[J]. 机械科学与技术，2009(6)：779-782. LI Mingsen，WU Xinyue，ZHANG Wenqun，et al. Pyramidal model and finite element analysis of metal rubber[J]. Mechanical Science and Technology，2009(6)：779-782.
[53] Tan Q，Liu P，DU C，et al. Mechanical behaviors of quasi-ordered entangled aluminum alloy wire material[J]. Materials Science and Engineering：A，2009，527(1-2)：38-44.
[54] 董秀萍，黄明吉，李星逸，等. 金属橡胶可变形材料三维参数化实体建模研究[J]. 材料科学与工艺，2010，18(6)：785-790. DONG Xiuping，HUANG Mingji，LI Xingyi，et al. Study on 3D parametric solid modeling of metal rubber deformable material[J]. Material Science and Technology，2010，18(6)：785-790.
[55] CAO S，YILMAZ E，YIN Z，et al. CT scanning of internal crack mechanism and strength behavior of cement- fiber-tailings matrix composites[J]. Cement and Concrete Composites，2021，116：103865.
[56] SENCU R M，YANG Z，WANG Y C，et al. Generation of micro-scale finite element models from synchrotron X-ray CT images for multidirectional carbon fibre reinforced composites[J]. Composites Part A：Applied Science and Manufacturing，2016，91：85-95.
[57] GARCEA S C，WANG Y，WITHERS P J. X-ray computed tomography of polymer composites[J]. Composites Science and Technology，2018，156：305-319.
[58] CAO W，ZHANG J，SUN B，et al. X-ray tomography and numerical study on low-velocity impact damages of three-dimensional angle-interlock woven composites[J]. Composite Structures，2019，230：111525.
[59] Courtois L，Maire E，Perez M，et al. Mechanical properties of monofilament entangled materials[J]. Advanced Engineering Materials，2012，14(12)：1128-1133.
[60] MA Y，ZHANG Q，WANG Y，et al. Topology and mechanics of metal rubber via X-ray tomography[J]. Materials & Design，2019，181：108067.
[61] 黄明吉，李斌，董秀萍. 基于三维骨架细化的金属橡胶三维建模方法研究[J]. 材料导报，2022，36(1)：174-178. HUANG Mingji，LI Bin，DONG Xiuping. Study on the 3D modeling method of metal rubber based on three- dimensional skeleton refinement[J]. Materials Reports，2022，36(1)：174-178.
[62] COURTOIS L，MAIRE E，PEREZ M，et al. Mechanical properties of Monofilament entangled materials[C]// Optical Measurements，Modeling，and Metrology，Volume 5：Proceedings of the 2011 Annual Conference on Experimental and Applied Mechanics. New York，NY：Springer New York，2011：33-38.
[63] DURVILLE D. Numerical simulation of entangled materials mechanical properties[J]. Journal of Materials Science，2005，40：5941-5948.
[64] RODNEY D，GADOT B，MARTINEZ O R，et al. Reversible dilatancy in entangled single-wire materials[J]. Nature Materials，2016，15(1)：72-77.
[65] 黄凯，白鸿柏，路纯红，等. 金属橡胶冲压成形数值模拟分析[J]. 稀有金属材料与工程，2016，45(3)：681-687. HUANG Kai，BAI Hongbai，LU Chunhong，et al. Numerical simulation analysis of metal rubber stamping forming[J]. Rare Metal Materials and Engineering，2016，45(3)：681-687.