Research on Injury Prevention Effectiveness of Cyclist Helmet in Typical Road Cycling Accident Scenarios

doi:10.3901/JME.2024.08.256

Abstract

Abstract: In intense and fast road cycling races, various accidents pose a great threat to cyclist safety. There is a lack of in-depth research on helmet performance and cyclist head injury in road cycling races. In this paper, based on collecting and summarizing the typical accident scenarios of road cycling races, models of road bicycle, anthropologic characteristics of cyclists and helmets are constructed with experimental and computational methods, and the head injury protection performance of helmets and cyclist's head injury response in typical accident scenarios are comprehensively analyzed and evaluated. The results show that the helmet can play a significant injury protection effect, but serious head injury may still occur in some scenarios; different helmets have significant differences in cyclist's head injury protection, and there is no direct correlation with the price. There are significant differences in the effectiveness of helmets for head injury protection among cyclists of different body sizes, with the 50th percentile adult men having the lowest peak kinematic response and injury risk, the 5th percentile adult women having the highest predicted values for all injury criteria, and at least 55% of female cyclists having a significant risk of skull fracture and severe brain injury. None of the accident boundary parameters examined in this study (accident speed, friction coefficient, and slope) had a significant effect on cyclist head injury in the accident scenarios; the Union cycliste Internationale stipulates that helmets may not be worn five kilometers from the end of the climb, while this study recommends cyclists wear safety helmets throughout the road cycling races. This study will provide a reference for the design of safety helmets for road cycling races, as well as data to support the improvement of road cycling race rules.

Key words: road cyclist, helmet, accident scenario, head injury, drop test, computational model

CLC Number:

U491

WANG Fang, HU Shenghui, HU Lin, PENG Ke, SHI Liangliang, WU Hequan, ZOU Tiefang, ZHOU Zhou. Research on Injury Prevention Effectiveness of Cyclist Helmet in Typical Road Cycling Accident Scenarios[J]. Journal of Mechanical Engineering, 2024, 60(8): 256-270.

References

[1] 王国亮，王芳，邓正龙，等. 双重预防机制下公路自行车赛事突发事件的应对与管理[J]. 世界体育，2018，778：18-19. WANG Guoliang，WANG Fang，DENG Zhenglong，et al. Response and management of road cycling emergencies under the dual prevention mechanism[J]. Sports World，2018，778：18-19.
[2] GREVE M W，MODABBER M R. An epidemic of traumatic brain injury in professional cycling： A call to action[J]. Clinical Journal of Sport Medicine，2012，22(2)：81-82.
[3] LUCIA A，HOYOS J，CHICHARRO J L. Physiology of professional road cycling[J]. Sports Medicine，2001，31(5)：325-335.
[4] EL HELOU N，BERTHELOT G，THIBAULT V，et al. Tour de France，Giro，Vuelta，and classic European races show a unique progression of road cycling speed in the last 20 years[J]. Journal of Sports Sciences，2010，28：789-796.
[5] YANTURALI S，CANACIK O，KARSLI E，et al. Injury and illness among athletes during a multi-day elite cycling road race[J]. The Physician and Sportsmedicine，2015，43(4)：348-354.
[6] 蔡睿，陈亮，何申杰，等. 公路自行车动力学分析及仿真研究[J]. 中国体育科技，2014，50(1)：125-128. CAI Rui，CHEN Liang，HE Shenjie，et al. Analysis on the dynamics and simulation of road cycling[J]. China Sport Science and Technology，2014，50(1)：125-128.
[7] SITKO S，CIRER-SASTRE R，CORBI F，et al. Power assessment in road cycling：A narrative review[J]. Sustainability，2020，12：1-14.
[8] CLARSEN B，KROSSHAUG T，BAHR R. Overuse injuries in professional road cyclists[J]. American Journal of Sports Medicine，2010，38(12)：2494-2501.
[9] LION A，VIBERT D，BOSSER G，et al. Vertigo in downhill mountain biking and road cycling[J]. European Journal of Sport Science，2016，16：135-140.
[10] 陈运魁. 公路自行车赛事风险管理研究[J]. 标准科学，2015(1)：72-75. CHEN Yunkui. Research on risk management of road cycling race[J]. Standard Science，2015(1)：72-75.
[11] KOTLYAR S. Cycling injuries in Southwest Colorado a comparison of road vs trail riding injury patterns[J]. Wilderness & Environmental Medicine，2016，27(2)：316-320.
[12] XU J，SHANG S，YU G，et al. Are electric self-balancing scooters safe in vehicle crash accidents?[J]. Accident Analysis and Prevention，2016，87：102-116.
[13] BÍL M，DOBIÁŠ M，ANDRÁŠIK R，et al. Cycling fatalities：When a helmet is useless and when it might save your life[J]. Safety Science，2018，105：71-76.
[14] FAHLSTEDT M，HALLDIN P，KLEIVEN S. Importance of the bicycle helmet design and material for the outcome in bicycle accidents[C]//3rd International Cycling Safety Conference (ICSC). Gothenburg，2014：1-14.
[15] ERHARDT T，RICE T，TROSZAK L，et al. Motorcycle helmet type and the risk of head injury and neck injury during motorcycle collisions in California[J]. Accident Analysis and Prevention，2016，86：23-28.
[16] OLIVIER J，CREIGHTON P. Bicycle injuries and helmet use：A systematic review and meta-analysis[J]. International Journal of Epidemiology，2017，46(1)：278-292.
[17] SONE J Y，KONDZIOLKA D，HUANG J H，et al. Helmet efficacy against concussion and traumatic brain injury：A review[J]. Journal of Neurosurgery，2017，126(3)：768-781.
[18] BLAND M L，ROWSON S. A price-performance analysis of the protective capabilities of wholesale bicycle helmets[J]. Traffic Injury Prevention，2021，22(6)：478-482.
[19] BLIVEN E，ROUHIER A，TSAI S，et al. Evaluation of a novel bicycle helmet concept in oblique impact testing[J]. Accident Analysis and Prevention，2019，124：58-65.
[20] FERNANDES F A O，ALVES DE SOUSA R J，PTAK M，et al. Certified motorcycle helmets：Computational evaluation of the efficacy of standard requirements with finite element models[J]. Mathematical and Computational Applications，2020，25(1)：12.
[21] FAHLSTEDT M，HALLDIN P，KLEIVEN S. The protective effect of a helmet in three bicycle accidents - A finite element study[J]. Accident Analysis and Prevention，2016，91：135-143.
[22] ABAYAZID F，DING K，ZIMMERMAN K，et al. A new assessment of bicycle helmets：The brain injury mitigation effects of new technologies in oblique impacts[J]. Annals of Biomedical Engineering，2021，49(10)：2716-2733.
[23] WANG F，WU J，HU L，et al. Evaluation of the head protection effectiveness of cyclist helmets using full-scale computational biomechanics modelling of cycling accidents[J]. Journal of Safety Research，2022，80：109-134.
[24] FAHLSTEDT M，ABAYAZID F，PANZER M B，et al. Ranking and rating bicycle helmet safety performance in oblique impacts using eight different brain injury models[J]. Annals of Biomedical Engineering，2021，49：1097-1109.
[25] GHAJARI M，PELDSCHUS S，GALVANETTO U，et al. Effects of the presence of the body in helmet oblique impacts[J]. Accident Analysis and Prevention，2013，50：263-271.
[26] Union Cycliste Internationale. UCI rainbow uses & equipment visual guidelines-manufacturer specifications & model variations[R]. Aigle，Switzerland：UCI，2022.
[27] NIE J，YANG J. A study of bicyclist kinematics and injuries based on reconstruction of passenger car-bicycle accident in China[J]. Accident Analysis and Prevention，2014，71：50-59.
[28] GAULRAPP H，WEBER A，ROSEMEYER B. Injuries in mountain biking[J]. Knee Surgery，Sports Traumatology，Arthroscopy，2001(9)：48-53.
[29] CLARK J M. In-depth analysis and reconstruction of equestrian jockey accidents and their helmets[D]. Dublin：University College Dublin，2019.
[30] 聂进，杨济匡. 基于汽车-自行车碰撞事故重建的骑车人动力学响应和损伤研究[J]. 汽车工程，2015，37(2)：160-167. NIE Jin，YANG Jikuang. A study on the dynamic response and injury of cyclist based on the car-bicycle accident reconstruction[J]. Automotive Engineering，2015，37(2)：160-167.
[31] DRORY A，YANAGISAWA M. Predictive mathematical model of time saved on descents in road cycling achieved through reduction in aerodynamic drag area[J]. Sports Engineering and Technology，2012，226(2)：152-160.
[32] DECOCK M，WILDE L D，BOSSCHE L V，et al. Incidence and aetiology of acute injuries during competitive road cycling[J]. British Journal of Sport Medicine，2016，50(11)：669-672.
[33] 王顺俗. 基于事故重建的自行车骑车人运动学与头部损伤研究[J]. 机电技术，2020(1)：66-69. WANG Shunsu. Research on kinematics and head injury of cyclists based on accident reconstruction[J]. Mechanical & Electrical Technology，2020(1)：66-69.
[34] 王鑫，张道文，冉启林，等. 电动自行车骑车人与汽车碰撞的动力学响应研究[J]. 中国安全科学学报，2016，26(6)：152-156. WANG Xin，ZHANG Daowen，RAN Qilin，et al. Cyclists’ dynamics response to car-electric bicycle crash[J]. China Safety Science Journal，2016，26(6)：152-156.
[35] MARTIN J C，MILLIKEN D L，COBB J E，et al. Validation of a mathematical model for road cycling power[J]. Journal of Applied Biomechanics，1998，14(3)：276-291.
[36] TNO. MADYMO Utilities manual version 7.5[R]. Helmond：TASS Intemational，2013.
[37] SHANG S，OTTE D，LI G，et al. Detailed assessment of pedestrian ground contact injuries observed from in-depth accident data[J]. Accident Analysis and Prevention，2018，110：9-17.
[38] ELLIOTT J R，SIMMS C K，WOOD D P. Pedestrian head translation，rotation and impact velocity： The influence of vehicle speed，pedestrian speed and pedestrian gait[J]. Accident Analysis and Prevention，2012，45：342-353.
[39] MILLS N J，GILCHRIST A. Bicycle helmet design[J]. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers Part L Journal of Materials Design & Applications，2006，220(4)：167-180.
[40] HUANG Y，ZHOU Q，KOELPER C，et al. Are riders of electric two-wheelers safer than bicyclists in collisions with motor vehicles?[J]. Accident Analysis and Prevention，2019，134：105336.
[41] WANG F，YU C，WANG B，et al. Prediction of pedestrian brain injury due to vehicle impact using computational biomechanics models：Are head-only models sufficient?[J]. Traffic Injury Prevention，2020，21(1)：102-107.
[42] WANG F，HUANG J，HU L，et al. Numerical investigation of the rider's head injury in typical single-electric self-balancing scooter accident scenarios[J]. Journal of the Royal Society Interface，2022，19(194)：20220495.
[43] 王方，蔡加欣，王丙雨，等. 基于行人碰撞事故重建的颅脑损伤准则效能研究[J]. 中国公路学报，2018，31(4)：231-240. WANG Fang，CAI Jiaxin，WANG Bingyu，et al. Investigation of prediction effectiveness of brain injury criteria on injury risk through reconstruction of pedestrian impact accidents[J]. China Journal of Highway and Transport，2018，31(4)：231-240.
[44] National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. Federal motor vehicle safety standards：Occupant crash protection[R]. Washington，United States：NHTSA，2010.
[45] VERSACE J. A review of the severity index[C]//15th Stapp Car Crash Conference. Warrendale，United States：SAE，710881，1971.
[46] TAKHOUNTS E G，CRAIG M J，MOORHOUSE K，et al. Development of brain injury criteria (BrIC)[J]. Stapp Car Crash Journal，2013，57：243-266.
[47] PRASAD P，MERTZ H J. The position of the United States delegation to the ISO working group 6 on the use of HIC in the automotive environment[C]//SAE Government Industry Meeting and Exposition. Warrendale，United States：SAE，1985：106-116.
[48] GENNARELLI T A，WODZIN E. Abbreviated injury scale 2005，update 2008[M]. Barrington，USA： Association for Advancement of Automatic Medicine，2008.
[49] MARJOUX D，BAUMGARTNER D，DECK C，et al. Head injury prediction capability of the HIC，HIP，SIMon and ULP criteria[J]. Accident Analysis and Prevention，2008，40(3)：1135-1148.
[50] 李一兵，袁泉，陈理. 车辆碰撞行人交通事故的不确定因素研究[J]. 中国公路学报，2004，17(1)：82-85. LI Yibing，YUAN Quan，CHEN Li. Study of uncertain factors in traffic accidents of vehicle impacting pedestrian[J]. China Journal of Highway and Transport，2004，17(1)：82-85.
[51] 孙明哲，裴玉龙. 道路摩擦系数测定方法若干问题的讨论[J]. 黑龙江交通科技，2004，20(10)：78-79. SUN Mingzhe，PEI Yulong. Discussion of several issues in the method of measuring the coefficient of friction of roads[J]. Communications Science and Technology Heilongjiang，2004，20(10)：78-79.
[52] MACDERMID P，FINK P，STANNARD S. The effects of vibrations experienced during road vs. off-road cycling[J]. International Journal of Sports Medicine，2015，36：783-788.