Investigation on Work Hardening Behavior of Bulk Metallic Glass under Nanoscale Wear

doi:10.3901/JME.2025.01.265

Abstract

Abstract: Based on an atomically flat Pt-based bulk metallic glass (Pt-BMG) processed by thermoplastic imprinting, the work hardening behavior of Pt-BMG under nanoscale wear is investigated by atomic force microscopy (AFM). It is found that the wear of Pt-BMG subjected to different number of cycles exhibited two distinct stages, and the wear rate at low load range (57 nN～108 nN) is significantly higher than that of the high load range (216～324 nN). This is because the wear under low loads is dominated by the surface oxide film, while the wear under high loads is controlled by the Pt-BMG matrix. With increasing the number of cycles from 1 to 10, the wear rate of Pt-BMG demonstrates a gradual decreasing trend, and the decreasing trend became more and more pronounced with the increase in cycle number. Specially, the wear rate of Pt-BMG is almost unchanged when the number of cycles is increased from 5 to 10; By decoupling the contribution of adhesive friction and plowing friction in wear with JKR model, the shear strength to displace the material ahead of the tip increases significantly from 3.32 GPa to 5.20 GPa with increasing the number of cycles from 1 to 5. Further increasing the cycle number to 10, the shear strength increases slightly to 5.41 GPa. This coincides with the trend of the wear rate versus the number of cycles, and thus verifies the existence of the work hardening effect of Pt-BMG occurred in nanoscale wear; The work hardening behavior observed in nanoscale wear of Pt-BMG is strongly dependent on the stress state and deformation scale, and the confined stress state under the nanoscale scratch condition promotes the atomic diffusive relaxation ability within the stressed volume in structure and inhibits the shear localization. As a result, the annihilation rate of free volume induced by structural relaxation is faster than that of free volume generation rate induced by shear dilation, therefore leading to the structural densification and the resultant work hardening effect.

Key words: bulk metallic glass, atomic force microscope, nanoscale wear, JKR model, work hardening

CLC Number:

TH117

ZHANG An, LIU Lingzhi, GU Zefang, ZHAO Fan, LAI Jianping, HU Hailong, YUAN Weifeng, YU Jiaxin. Investigation on Work Hardening Behavior of Bulk Metallic Glass under Nanoscale Wear[J]. Journal of Mechanical Engineering, 2025, 61(1): 265-273.

References

[1] LIU Tianhao，LAI Limin，XIAO Siming，et al. Ternary Fe-W-B bulk metallic glasses with ultrahigh thermal stabilities[J]. Materials Science and Engineering：A，2021，826：142034.
[2] WANG Weihua. Dynamic relaxations and relaxation-property relationships in metallic glasses[J]. Progress in Materials Science，2019，106：100561.
[3] CHEN Yu，DAI Zhengwei，JIANG Jianzhong. High entropy metallic glasses：Glass formation，crystallization and properties[J]. Journal of Alloys and Compounds，2021，866：158852.
[4] HUFNAGEL T C，SCHUH C A，FALK M L. Deformation of metallic glasses：Recent developments in theory，simulations，and experiments[J]. Acta Materialia，2016，109：375-393.
[5] ZHANG Kun，HU Zheng，LI Fengjiang，et al. Viscous surface flow induced on Ti-based bulk metallic glass by heavy ion irradiation[J]. Applied Surface Science，2016，390：941-945.
[6] JAGDALE S，HU Q，ECKER M，et al. Biocompatibility and thermoplastic formability of Pt-based metallic glasses[J]. Materials Letters，2021，295：129870.
[7] LIU Xue，GU Jialun，YANG Guannan，et al. Theoretical and experimental study of metallic glass die-imprinting for manufacturing large-size micro/nano structures[J]. Journal of Materials Processing Technology，2022，307：117699.
[8] 章海明，徐帅，李倩，等. 晶体塑性理论及模拟研究进展[J]. 塑性工程学报，2020，27(5)：12-32. ZHANG Haiming，XU Shuai，LI Qian，et al. Progress of crystal plasticity theory and simulations[J]. Journal of Plasticity Engineering，2020，27(5)：12-32
[9] GREER J R，OLIVER W C，NIX W D. Size dependence of mechanical properties of gold at the micron scale in the absence of strain gradients[J]. Acta Materialia，2005，53(6)：1821-1830.
[10] GREER J R，DE HOSSON J T M. Plasticity in small-sized metallic systems：Intrinsic versus extrinsic size effect[J]. Progress in Materials Science，2011，56(6)：654-724.
[11] GHIDELLI M，IDRISSI H，GRAVIER S，et al. Homogeneous flow and size dependent mechanical behavior in highly ductile Zr65Ni35 metallic glass films[J]. Acta Materialia，2017，131：246-259.
[12] VOLKERT C A，DONOHUE A，SPAEPEN F. Effect of sample size on deformation in amorphous metals[J]. Journal of Applied Physics，2008，103(8)：083539.
[13] CHEN C Q，PEI Y T，DE HOSSON J T M. Effects of size on the mechanical response of metallic glasses investigated through in situ TEM bending and compression experiments[J]. Acta Materialia，2010，58(1)：189-200.
[14] JANG Dongchan，GREER J R. Transition from a strong-yet-brittle to a stronger-and-ductile state by size reduction of metallic glasses[J]. Nature Materials，2010，9(3)：215-219.
[15] KUMAR G，DESAI A，SCHROERS J. Bulk metallic glass：the smaller the better[J]. Advanced Materials，2011，23(4)：461-476.
[16] NACHUM S，GREER A L. Indentation size effect in metallic glasses：Mean pressure at the initiation of plastic flow[J]. Journal of Alloys and Compounds，2014，615：S98-S101.
[17] CARTER J，FU E G，MARTIN M，et al. Effects of Cu ion irradiation in Cu₅₀Zr₄₅Ti₅ metallic glass[J]. Scripta Materialia，2009，61(3)：265-268.
[18] XIAO Qiran，HUANG Liping，SHI Yunfeng. Suppression of shear banding in amorphous ZrCuAl nanopillars by irradiation[J]. Journal of Applied Physics，2013，113(8)：083514.
[19] RAHAMAN M L，ZHANG L，LIU M，et al. Surface roughness effect on the friction and wear of bulk metallic glasses[J]. Wear，2015，332-333：1231-1237.
[20] ADIBI S，BRANICIO P S，LIONTAS R，et al. Surface roughness imparts tensile ductility to nanoscale metallic glasses[J]. Extreme Mechanics Letters，2015，5：88-95.
[21] LI Rui，CHEN Zheng，DATYE A，et al. Atomic imprinting into metallic glasses[J]. Communications Physics，2018，1(1)：75.
[22] JOHNSON K L，KENDALL K，ROBERTS A D，et al. Surface energy and the contact of elastic solids[J]. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London A Mathematical and Physical Sciences，1997，324(1558)：301-313.
[23] SCHROERS J. Glasses made from pure metals[J]. Nature，2014，512(7513)：142-143.
[24] 余家欣，钱林茂. 一种改进的原子力显微镜摩擦力标定方法[J]. 摩擦学学报，2007，27(5)：472-476. YU Jiaxin，QIAN Linmao. An improved calibration method for friction force in atomic force microscopy[J]. Tribology，2007，27(5)：472-476.
[25] KANG S J，RITTGEN K T，KWAN S G，et al. Importance of surface oxide for the tribology of a Zr-based metallic glass[J]. FRICTION，2017，5(1)：115-122.
[26] JIA Qian，HE Wenhao，HUA Dongpeng，et al. Effects of structure relaxation and surface oxidation on nanoscopic wear behaviors of metallic glass[J]. Acta Materialia，2022，232：117934.
[27] LOUZGUINE-LUZGIN D V，NGUYEN H K，NAKAJIMA K，et al. A study of the nanoscale and atomic-scale wear resistance of metallic glasses[J]. Materials Letters，2016，185：54-58.
[28] RAMAZANOVA Z M，ZAMALITDINOVA M G. Study of the properties of qxide coatings formed on titanium by plasma electrolytic oxidation method[J]. Eurasian Chemico-Technological Journal，2020，22(1)：51-58.
[29] MIRSANEH M，REANEY I M，HATTON P V，et al. Characterization of high-fracture toughness k-fluorrichterite-fluorapatite glass ceramics[J]. Journal of the American Ceramic Society，2004，87(2)：240-246.
[30] DESHPANDE A V，SATYANARAYANA P. Study of lithium disilicate based nano glass ceramics containing P₂O₅[J]. Silicon，2022，14(15)：9973-9986.
[31] LUMPP J K，CHEN N，GORETTA K C. Mechanical properties of CuO[J]. High Temperature Materials and Processes，1990，9(1)：1-6.
[32] SCHROERS J，JOHNSON W L. Ductile bulk metallic glass[J]. Physical Review Letters，2004，93(25)：255506.
[33] MADGE S V，CARON A，GRALLA R，et al. Novel W-based metallic glass with high hardness and wear resistance[J]. Intermetallics，2014，47：6-10.
[34] ZHAO Shuji，SHI Songlin，XIA Kailun，et al. Scratching of graphene-coated Cu substrates leads to hardened cu interfaces with enhanced lubricity[J]. ACS Applied Nano Materials，2020，3(2)：1992-1998.
[35] BEAKE B D，HARRIS A J，LISKIEWICZ T W，et al. Friction and electrical contact resistance in reciprocating nano-scale wear testing of metallic materials[J]. Wear，2021，474-475：203866.
[36] BOWDEN F P，TABOR D. The friction and lubrication of solids[M]. Oxford：Oxford University Press，2001.
[37] MEYER E，LÜTHI R，HOWALD L，et al. Site‐specific friction force spectroscopy[J]. Journal of Vacuum Science & Technology B：Microelectronics and Nanometer Structures Processing，Measurement，and Phenomena，1996，14(2)：1285-1288.
[38] KO H E，PARK H W，JIANG J Z，et al. Nanoscopic wear behavior of face centered cubic metals[J]. Acta Materialia，2018，147：203-212.
[39] WANG Jianfeng，LI R，HUA Nengbin，et al. Co-based ternary bulk metallic glasses with ultrahigh strength and plasticity[J]. Journal of Materials Research，2011，26(16)：2072-2079.
[40] LI J，WANG Z L，HUFNAGEL T C. Characterization of nanometer-scale defects in metallic glasses by quantitative high-resolution transmission electron microscopy[J]. Physical Review B，2002，65(14)：144201.
[41] JIANG W H，PINKERTON F E，ATZMON M. Mechanical behavior of shear bands and the effect of their relaxation in a rolled amorphous Al-based alloy[J]. Acta Materialia，2005，53(12)：3469-3477.
[42] SHAO Yang，YAO Kefu，LI Mo，et al. Two-zone heterogeneous structure within shear bands of a bulk metallic glass[J]. Applied Physics Letters，2013，103(17)：171901.
[43] LAM D C C，CHONG A C M. Model and experiments on strain gradient hardening in metallic glass[J]. Materials Science and Engineering：A，2001，318(1)：313-319.
[44] JIANG Shuangshuang，ZHU Li，LIU Sinan，et al. Densification and heterogeneity enhancement of Fe-based metallic glass under local plastic flow[J]. Acta Physica Sinica，2022，71(5)：058101.
[45] ZHAO Dan，ZHAO Hongwei，ZHU Bo，et al. Investigation on hardening behavior of metallic glass under cyclic indentation loading via molecular dynamics simulation[J]. Applied Surface Science，2017，416：14-23.
[46] AL-AQEELI N. Strengthening behavior due to cyclic elastic loading in Pd-based metallic glass[J]. Journal of Alloys and Compounds，2011，509(26)：7216-7220.